Disclaimer: This story is
written for entertainment purposes only.
No profit is being made from it.
No infringement on anyones copyrights is intended.
Justice
Written by Sue David and Valerie Wells
© May 2001
We thank our technical consultant Hutchrules3
~*~*~*~
Starsky and Hutch were arguing
amiably as they entered the squad room that morning. Starsky, waving his hands
for emphasis, insisted, "I'm tellin' ya, Hutch, it's the next big thing.
And you can do it, I know you can."
"Starsky," Hutch said,
more or less patiently, "I am not going to play punk rock. No WAY am I
going to play punk rock."
"But the kinda music you
like," Starsky went on, plopping his bottom on the table and propping his
feet on a chair, "good as it is, it just don't sell, buddy. We could make
a million bucks."
"We?" Hutch inquired,
smothering a grin. "Where do you fit into all this?"
"I'll be your manager,"
Starsky said.
Dobey stood in his office doorway
and listened, reluctant to interrupt. The paper he held in his hand was going
to destroy those smiles and make their next few weeks miserable.
"I'm a cop, moron," Hutch
said, pouring himself and Starsky cups of coffee. He held Starsky's out to him,
and Starsky took it, took a sip and set it down. "I'm not a professional
singer, so what does it matter what kind of music I sing?"
"You could be a
professional," Starsky said. "You're good enough. You could start out
slow, doin' gigs in the bars, until you built up a following, and then "
Hutch rolled his eyes and Starsky
paused.
"You could!" he said
defensively.
"Sure, I could," Hutch
said. "I can see the marquee now. 'Ken Hutchinson, The Singing Cop.'"
"That ain't bad," Starsky
said approvingly. "You'll need a gimmick. That might do the trick."
Hutch grinned and sang the song Starsky
had been humming for the last few weeks, "'Echo Valley 2-6809, I used to
call that number all the time, but the last time that I called you, we hung up
cryin'.'." He turned his eyes toward his captain to include him in the
banter. "What d'you think, Cap? Maybe I'll even perform in uniform, give
the girls a thrill."
Starsky snorted. "You ain't
gonna sing Partridge Family songs, Hutch. Punk rock. I'm tellin' ya...."
Dobey drew a deep breath. "I
need to see you two in my office."
The two detectives exchanged a look.
And without a word, Starsky slid off the table, snagged his coffee on the way,
and followed Hutch and Dobey into the office, closing the door behind him. He
sat down in one chair and Hutch hitched his chair a little closer to Starsky's
before sitting down. Both waited expectantly, all humor gone from their faces.
Dobey laid the paper in front of him
on the desk and rubbed his hands over his head. "I've got some news."
"Lay it on us, Cap,"
Starsky said.
Dobey looked from one to the other
for a moment first. These two liked it straight from the shoulder, no beating
around the bush, no breaking it easy. "Prudholm's been certified fit for
trial."
Starsky's face went a shade paler
and Hutch reached out and laid a hand on his arm. There was short silence.
"Which case?" Hutch asked
finally.
Dobey sighed. "Terry."
"Charge?"
"Murder one."
Starsky still had not spoken. He
looked down into his coffee cup for several moments while Hutch gently stroked
his arm.
"Dave," Dobey said very
quietly, "I know this is going to be hard for you. Do you need a couple of
days off?"
Starsky, eyes still down, shook his
head.
"We'll need to pull the
file," Hutch said to Dobey. "Track down the witnesses again, get the
stories straight "
"The D.A.'s doing that," Dobey
said. "He'll be in touch with you. You'll have to testify."
"We know," Hutch answered
for both of them.
"Hutch, can you make a list of
people that won't be in the official file, for the D.A.?"
Hutch nodded without looking away
from Starsky. "That'd be Dr. Quo, for one. Christine, maybe, you think,
Starsk? We'll need a victim statement and she can testify to the effect on
Terry and on you "
Starsky wet his lips, nodded once,
but still didn't speak. Hutch turned his eyes to Dobey with a mute plea in them.
"I need a cup of coffee,"
Dobey said, understanding. "I'll be back in a few minutes." He rose,
picked up his half-full cup, and left the room, closing the door behind him.
Hutch waited.
It took several more moments, but
finally Starsky said, softly and hoarsely, "I don't know if I can do it,
partner."
"Yes, you can," Hutch
said. "For Terry, you can do it."
"Gonna have to relive the whole
thing."
"I know." Hutch moved his
hand to Starsky's shoulder. "I'll be with you all the way."
Starsky nodded again, but did not
look at Hutch.
Hutch stayed where he was, gently
squeezing the shoulder under his hand and feeling the tension in the muscles
there. The long dark lashes stayed down. Hutch knew there were tears in
Starsky's eyes, tears Starsky didn't want him to see. It had been almost three
years, but Starsky never spoke of Terry if he could help it, and when he did,
there was always a tell-tale tremor in his voice. At last, Starsky drew a long,
deep breath and raised his eyes, in tenuous control again. "Let's do
it."
The day was long and mostly quiet.
Starsky wasn't inclined to chit-chat and Hutch mostly left him to his own
thoughts, taking over the driving with no argument from his partner. He knew
Starsky's mind would not be on traffic.
Fortunately, it was a quiet shift,
with few calls and none of them requiring much of them. The only one that
caused any real adrenaline rush was a domestic disturbance, and by the time
they arrived the combatants, a newly married couple, had made up. It had only
been an argument, albeit a noisy one, and the neighbors had called the police
as a precaution.
"We'll try to fight more
quietly next time, Officer," the bride said, her eyes still a bit red from
crying, but twinkling at the same time.
Hutch grinned in return. He'd answered
enough domestic calls in his time to tell the difference between a real problem
and a temporary disagreement. The groom, looking very much ashamed of himself,
apologized profusely for "wasting" his and Starsky's time.
"It's okay," Hutch assured
him. "Part of our job. We'd rather come when there's nothing wrong than
miss helping out when there is."
As they drove away, the young man
had his arm around his wife and was bent, whispering something that made her
smile.
"Cute couple," Hutch
remarked, not expecting an answer.
"Yeah," Starsky said,
turning his head to watch them out of sight over his shoulder. "Makin'
up's half the fun."
Hutch chuckled, but Starsky wasn't
smiling, and he stopped. "You okay?"
"Yeah." And Starsky had
held his peace for almost an hour after the call.
Starsky was very insistent that he
didn't need Hutch to "baby-sit" him so, with many misgivings, Hutch
left him at his doorstep and drove home. He let himself in with the key he now
kept in his pocket it had finally dawned on him that he shouldn't leave his
key above the door and tossed his jacket and holster into a chair. He opened
the closet and reached into the back for a cardboard box with a lid. He took it
to his bed and sat down, steeling himself mentally before opening it.
He reached for the slightly battered
white teddy bear that lay inside. Ollie.
Three years and he could still
remember, word for word, the letter that Terry had left for him with the bear.
"Dearest Hutch,
To you I entrust Ollie and Dave.
Please love them both, and don't let either one of them change."
He'd read that much aloud to his
partner, through the thickness in his throat, as the words blurred in front of
his tear-filled eyes. He'd looked at Starsky, whose eyes were filled with pain,
and had seen the struggle as Starsky tried to be strong. And that's why he
couldn't finish, couldn't read the last line to him. He'd simply stopped, and
let Starsky think that was the end of the note. Someday, when Starsky could
handle it, he'd told himself, he'd let him see the rest.
But that day had never come. And
now, Hutch reached into the box again, and withdrew the note he'd kept. He
looked down, and again tears filled his eyes as he read the last line:
"After all, what are best
friends for?"
It was signed, "Love from
Terry."
Starsky had never asked to see the
note. Hutch knew there had also been something written inside the cover of the
"1001 Ways to Win at Monopoly" book she'd left for Starsky, something
Starsky had never shown him.
Hutch had tried to give Ollie to
Starsky, assuming that he would want something that Terry had kept close to
her, but Starsky had refused.
"No, Hutch. She wanted you to
look out for him. Besides," Starsky had shaken his head, "I don't
think I could stand havin' him around."
And now, even though Hutch fervently
believed that Prudholm belonged in prison, not in a mental hospital, and this
trial would see to it that he went to prison, he shuddered away from the
thought of what the trial would put Starsky through.
Starsky sat cross-legged on his
couch, with photographs scattered all around him. Through the photos he'd taken
of Terry and the kids she taught, of Hutch and Christine and Terry, of Terry
alone, he relived the months of falling in love with her, of their lives
becoming entwined until life without her was unthinkable. Until she'd been
shot, he'd never formally asked her to marry him. He hadn't had to. It was
understood. Terry had refused to move in with him, insisting on keeping her own
apartment and her independence "until it's legal," she'd said
with that saucy grin. He'd grinned back and agreed.
It was so easy with Terry. She'd
accepted Hutch and the two of them had become bosom buddies in no time flat.
She fit into their partnership comfortably and never complained, except
jokingly, when work kept Starsky out late or forced him to break a date. She
had her own friends, her own life, her own career. She never tried to own
Starsky or ask more of him than he was willing to give.
But he'd wanted to give her his life
and his heart. And when she died, she left a hole that no one would ever fill
again.
He reached for the little book that
he still kept in his bedside table. It was an old joke between them, how badly
he played Monopoly.
"You're just not cutthroat enough,"
Terry had complained with twinkling eyes. "You're too damned nice about
it. You can't be nice in Monopoly." She'd sighed then, theatrically, and
said, "Obviously, I'll have to handle the money when we're married. I
can't trust you with it. We'd be living under a bridge in two weeks."
He'd been agreeable. "Your wish
is my command," he'd said. Another old joke. He pretended she henpecked
him, though theirs was the most equal give-and-take relationship he'd ever had,
except the one with Hutch. In fact, Terry was a lot like Hutch in some ways.
She saw through him, knew his weakness and his strength, and loved him anyway.
He opened the little book.
"Remember," she'd written,
"I'll always be there. When you're alone, whenever you need me, I'll be
there."
He'd never shown it to Hutch, though
he'd told him, while he'd been numb and aching all at once in those first bleak
moments after her death, what her last words had been. This was a message for
his eyes only.
He closed his eyes, quieted his
mind, and reached out. She'd been right. Whenever he needed her, when he woke
up alone late at night with his heart still aching, even now, he could feel her
love surrounding him, comforting him.
He was going to need that to lean on
during the trial. That... and Hutch.
Hutch drove over to Starsky's
apartment a little early the next morning. He wanted to make sure his partner
was all right before they started their shift. The previous day was hard on
both of them. Hutch knew all the pain and grief of Terry's death had just
resurfaced. Not that Starsky kept it at bay all the time. Although he thought
Hutch didn't know, Starsky often thought of Terry and the hole she had left in
his life. Some days, he found it hard to believe he was ever going to meet
another lady who would fit into his life and consume his heart as Terry had.
Hutch knocked on the door, but
received no answer. He let himself in with his key and quietly stepped into the
darkened living room. Starsky hadn't even opened the shutters yet.
Looking toward the sofa, he knew
why. His partner was curled up on the sofa, restlessly sleeping, with
"1001 Ways to Win Monopoly" held tightly against his chest. He hadn't
even heard Hutch enter.
"Aw, buddy, you're still in
your clothes from yesterday," Hutch quietly said as he knelt next to
Starsky and gently shook his shoulder. "Come on, buddy, it's
morning."
Starsky opened his eyes, completely
without surprise at finding his partner in the middle of his living room.
"Hutch, oh, I must have fallen asleep. I'm sorry." He sat up and
rubbed his eyes, letting the book slide behind him onto the couch.
"You were supposed to be
asleep, Gordo. You okay?"
"Yeah. Guess I'd better grab a
quick shower."
"I'll make some coffee and
breakfast. You got anything besides cold pizza?" Hutch hoped to at least
get a smile out of that comment. He didn't.
"Nah, you go ahead. I've got
some eggs in there. Sorry, no wheat germ or desiccated organ meats in there,
though."
"Aren't you gonna eat?"
Starsky called over his shoulder as
he closed the bathroom door, "Not hungry."
Hutch stared at the closed door for
a minute thinking about how unfair it was that something always seemed to be
knocking down his partner. How could so much happen to one person? Why did it
keep happening to his best friend?
While he made the coffee, Hutch
called Dobey. "Mornin', Cap."
"How's he doin'?"
"Not too good. He looks pretty
bad."
"I knew this was gonna be tough
on him. He okay to work?"
"Yeah, he needs to work.
Otherwise he's just gonna sit around this apartment not sleeping and not
eating."
"Where are you two gonna
start?"
"I brought home the info on the
witnesses from the staged hold up. Thought we'd run them down this morning. I
don't want to bring him in for a while. He needs to be out moving around and
working the witnesses."
"Okay. You probably should know
jury selection is starting today. They think the trial will be under way by
Thursday."
"They bringing Prudholm down to
lock-up?"
"Yeah, tomorrow morning."
"Okay, I think I'd better keep
him out of there, then, too."
"Good luck, Hutch. I know this
isn't easy on you either."
"Thanks, Cap."
Next, Hutch placed a call to the
hospital.
"This is Detective Ken
Hutchinson, Bay City PD. I need to speak with Dr. Quo."
He reached into the refrigerator
while he waited, getting out a cold Dr. Pepper for Starsky. His partner liked
his caffeine cold most mornings. Seeing the bareness of Starsky's fridge made
him shake his head. "Aw, Starsk. You ever gonna get back to eating
right?"
"This is Dr. Quo."
"Detective Hutchinson, Dr. Quo.
Do you remember me?"
"Yes, from the Terry Roberts
case. Is David all right?"
He was touched both by her concern
and the fact that she remembered them after so many years.
"He's fine, Doc."
"I followed the newspapers when
he was shot. I also spoke with his doctor about David. He did a fine job."
"Yes, he did." Hutch
smiled softly, thinking about all the people who cared about Starsky and he
didn't even know it. "Dr. Quo, the man who shot Terry has been cleared to
stand trial. We'd like to come over and speak with you this morning. Do you
have a few minutes?"
"Certainly. I have some time
around ten. Can you meet me in the cafeteria?"
"We'll see you then."
Starsky emerged from the bathroom
and headed in to get dressed without a word. Hutch knew this was going to be a
rough day and his primary job was going to be holding his partner together.
~*~*~*~
"Where're we goin'?"
Starsky inquired, starting the car.
"To see the guy who runs the
store where Terry was shot," Hutch said.
Starsky turned in his seat and
studied Hutch for a moment. "We're not going to check in first?"
"I already did. From your
place."
Starsky was silent, but his jaw was
set in the tight line that meant it was taking everything he had not to blow.
Hutch glanced at him. "We don't
have to do this, buddy. Dobey can assign someone else. The offer to take a
couple of days off "
"Is crap, and you know
it," Starsky said, and his control slipped, just a little. Enough so that
his voice shook, ever so slightly. Someone who didn't know him very, very well
might not have even noticed it. "The last thing I need is nothin' to do. I
gotta do this. I just " His voice faltered and he turned his head away
and looked out the window.
Hutch kept his eyes averted,
allowing Starsky what privacy he could in the confines of the car.
After a moment, Starsky drew a deep
breath, and Hutch could almost feel the effort it cost him. "I'm okay,
Hutch," was all he said, but Hutch nodded.
When Starsky pulled the Torino up in
front of the small store where Terry met her fate, he turned the car off and
sat still for a few minutes. Hutch put his hand on Starsky's shoulder and gave
it a gentle squeeze. "You okay, partner?"
"Yeah, I was just remembering.
. . that night."
"Want me to go in alone?"
"I'll go with you." He
looked up at Hutch with eyes full of painful memories. Hutch would ask the
questions. Starsky wanted it that way.
Hutch showed his ID to the man
behind the counter.
"I'm Detective Hutchinson, this
is Detective Starsky."
"What can I do for you
officers?"
"We need to speak with John
Clark. Is he here?"
The man looked uncomfortable.
"Uh, no. He got himself killed in a holdup here about a year ago."
Starsky's face showed his
disappointment. The store owner had been one of the witnesses that night. Their
first catch and the man was dead.
"How long have you worked
here?"
"Dunno exactly. Probably five
years."
"Were you here on the night a
young woman was shot during a robbery attempt about three years ago?"
"Yeah, I was here. Crazy dude just
hauled off and shot her. She didn't do nothin', he just shot her. Had
nightmares about that for a long time."
"You and me both," Starsky
said as he turned and walked outside.
"The man who did it is finally
coming to trial. You may be called as a witness, will you testify?"
"Yeah, I'll testify. I hope
they fry him."
Hutch got the man's contact
information and thanked him."Someone from the District Attorney's office
will be in touch." Walking back out into the bright sunlight, Hutch saw
that Starsky was sitting on the hood of the Torino, staring into space.
"Starsk?"
"It's been three years, Hutch.
What if we can't find the right witnesses?"
"We will, Gordo. That guy said
he'd testify. Everything will be all right."
"Will it?"
"I wish I could make this easier
for you, buddy. It's just gonna be hard, but I'm here."
Starsky nodded his thanks and
climbed back behind the wheel, waiting for Hutch to join him for the trip to
meet with Dr. Quo.
She was waiting for them in the
hospital cafeteria. She already had three cups of coffee at the table when they
arrived. When they were seated at the table with her, she turned to Starsky.
"David, how have you been?"
"I'm all right, Doc."
"You don't look all right
today, David."
Dr. Quo was perceptive. Starsky was
pale and the hand holding his coffee cup was shaking almost imperceptibly.
Hutch had also noticed it and he was keeping a close eye on his partner.
"It's just a little hard, Doc.
You know, remembering all this about Terry."
"I know. How can I help?"
"I'm sure the District Attorney
will call you as a witness."
"Yes, they also contacted me
this morning. They want Terry's medical records."
Starsky stared right through her,
remembering the pain of the day Terry finally succumbed to the bullet Prudholm
put in her head. He remembered his anguish when Dr. Quo told him there was
nothing more she could do.
"Doc, Prudholm, the man who
killed Terry, has been in a psychiatric hospital for three years. He has
finally been judged sane enough to stand trial for her murder. Getting a
conviction is important to us."
"Don't worry, I'm going to
review her file and her X-Rays. I'll be ready."
Starsky's eyes were bright and Hutch
could see what a hard time he was having being there. He hadn't said much, but
he did need to tell Dr. Quo something.
"Doc, I know you did everything
you could for Terry. Thank you for helping at least make her comfortable."
"You're welcome, David."
She reached across the table and patted him on the arm. He was very close to
tears. He nodded at her, excused himself and walked out of the cafeteria.
Dr. Quo looked at Hutch, her dark
eyes filled with compassion for Starsky. "He doesn't look good. Please see
that he gets some rest."
"I know, Doc. This is so hard
on him. He needs to do this, though. Maybe when this is all over, he finally
will be able to have some peace about Terry."
"I hope so. If you need me, if
he does, please call me. I'd like to help."
"Thanks. I'd better go find out
where he went now." Hutch shook her hand gratefully and left in search of
his partner.
He caught up with Starsky, sitting
outside on a bench in the sun. Maybe this was just going to be too much for his
friend. He wondered how Starsky would handle it when they called him as a
witness.
"Hey. How about we go back to your
place for a while. Take a break from these interviews."
"I'm okay."
"Well, you haven't eaten
anything yet. Want to go over to Huggy's for a bite?"
Starsky turned and looked at his
best friend. He knew Hutch would do anything in his power to shield him from
pain, but he could feel that Hutch was hurting, too.
"How are YOU doing,
Blondie?"
"Hurts. Feels kinda good to be
doing something about it, though."
"You're right. Let's keep
moving. Okay?" Starsky slid off the bench and started for the car, and as
he passed Hutch, he gave him a little pat on the arm. That gesture told Hutch
"thanks for being here" more clearly than words would have. He bit
his lower lip, swallowed, and followed Starsky to the car.
The next nearest place was the
school where Terry had taught. Starsky turned the car that direction without
even discussing it with Hutch. He pulled up at the curb and sat quietly for a
moment, his eyes on the basketball court, but the expression in them was far
away.
"I haven't been here for a long
time," Starsky said, as if speaking to himself. He sighed and let his eyes
wander over to the picnic tables that stood along the side of the asphalt.
Hutch waited and watched his partner's face. He could almost hear the voices of
the kids and the sound of sneakers on blacktop, though at this hour the
playground was deserted. The two picnic tables were empty now, but still sat in
roughly the same positions they had then...this was where Starsky had come
after Terry died, to be alone, to try to come to grips with what had happened.
"You ready?" Starsky
asked, opening his door.
"Yeah." Hutch followed him
into the school.
Starsky walked straight to the
administrator's office without pausing, while Hutch followed behind, and when
they reached it, Starsky paused, straightened his shoulders, and walked in. He
stopped at the counter and cleared his throat. The secretary looked up.
"Yes, sir?"
Starsky produced his badge.
"Detectives Starsky and Hutchinson. May we see Mrs. Rachman, please?"
"She retired last year,"
the secretary said. "Would you like to talk to Mr. Getty? He's her
replacement."
Starsky glanced at Hutch and that
hopeless look was back in his eyes, saying as clearly as words, "Another
witness gone."
But Hutch's mind was working more
clearly than his partner's. "Wasn't he a teacher before? Jack Getty?"
The secretary nodded. "He
taught the high school children until he took over as administrator."
"You remember him,
Starsk," Hutch prodded. "He was the P.E. teacher, too."
"May I tell him what this is
about?" the secretary asked.
Starsky glanced at Hutch again.
"Terry Roberts," Hutch
said. The secretary nodded and picked up the phone and Hutch leaned closer to
Starsky and whispered, "We can still interview Mrs. Rachman. It doesn't
matter if she's retired."
"I know," Starsky said.
"Life goes on."
Hutch didn't have an answer to that,
and was saved from having to think of one by Getty's appearance in his office
door.
"Dave! Ken! Come in!" He
smiled at both of them. "It's been too long."
Starsky and Hutch glanced at each
other and obeyed Getty's gesture to enter his office. Taking a couple of
chairs, they sat down and waited while Getty closed the door and seated
himself. Then the smile disappeared from his face.
"I know why you're here,"
he said quietly. "The secretary's new. She wasn't here...when Terry was.
How are you doing, Dave?"
"I'm okay," Starsky said
in a tone that told he was anything but.
Getty nodded and flicked his eyes to
Hutch. "We really miss Terry," he said. "She was so good with
the shy kids especially. Sally blossomed in her class. You should see her now,
Dave. She's started helping with the younger kids and she's wonderful with
them."
Starsky smiled a little. "I'm
glad to hear it."
"I'll bet Sally'd love to say
hello," Getty went on.
Starsky's lashes fell and Hutch gave
Getty a "back off" look.
Getty understood. "What can I
do for you guys?"
"Prudholm the guy who
murdered Terry is going to trial," Hutch said, taking over. "We
need to line up our witnesses. We came to see Mrs. Rachman, since she was in
charge when Terry was here, but we'll need you, too. You were here the day
Terry " He couldn't finish.
"Yes, I was," Getty said.
"I remember how upset the kids were. They knew something was wrong, but
they didn't know what until later. Thanks for breaking it to them, Ken."
Starsky turned and looked at Hutch.
He hadn't known that.
Hutch returned the look. "Can
you tell us how to reach Mrs. Rachman?"
"Sure. She's living in Ojai,
near her daughter. I have her number somewhere." Getty poked through his
desk until he found an address book and a piece of paper. He paged through the
book for a few moments and copied a number onto the paper, leaning across the
desk to hand it to Hutch. "What will you want from me, when the time
comes?"
"The D.A. will go over that
with you," Hutch said. "Mostly, I think, he'll want you to tell about
Terry's work here and how she's missed and what kind of impact she had on the
children. That kind of thing."
"I'll be glad to," Getty
said.
Hutch glanced at Starsky again. He'd
had all he could take, so Hutch touched his arm. "Come on, buddy. Let's
go."
Starsky nodded and rose. He offered
his hand to Getty, but didn't speak. Getty gripped it hard. "Take care,
Dave."
Starsky nodded again and left the
room.
"Ken," Getty said as Hutch
turned to follow him. Hutch waited. "Is he really okay?"
Hutch shrugged. "I don't know,
Jack. As okay as you can be when some thug has killed your lady to get back at
you."
Getty winced. "Yeah."
They left the school and had started
to cross the sidewalk when a young voice called out, "Mr. Dave! Mr. Dave,
wait!"
Both men turned and saw Sally,
looking much the same age, but with a new air of maturity about her. She was
waving with her arm over her head and she trotted out of the school and down
the sidewalk toward them.
"I just want to say I'm
sorry," Sally said, stopping in front of Starsky and looking up at him.
"About Miss Roberts. I never got to tell you before. I miss her a
lot."
"So do I," Starsky said,
his eyes suspiciously bright. He opened his arms and Sally, shy Sally who had
hardly been able to look another person in the eye before Terry started working
with her, gave him a hug. As they approached the Torino, Starsky wordlessly
handed Hutch his keys. Hutch took them and walked around to the driver's side,
peering at his partner over the roof of the car. Starsky looked completely
drained. He knew the man needed to breathe a little.
Hutch slid in behind the wheel.
"Well, buddy, I don't know
'bout you, but I'm kinda hungry. Thirsty too."
Starsky just nodded.
"Let's head over to Huggy's.
Well take a lunch break, and then go on into the precinct to check in with
Dobey.
"I'm not hungry, Hutch."
"I know, partner, but you can
at least get something to drink. You haven't had anything all day."
"All right."
Hutch pulled away from the curb and
headed for The Pits.
When they walked into The Pits,
Huggy looked up and gave them his usual cheerful greeting.
"Well, if it ain't my two
favorite flat feet."
"Hi, Hug," Hutch said. Starsky
just gave him a small jerk of his chin in greeting. Then he immediately excused
himself to wash up before lunch, quickly walking toward the men's room.
"Man, what's up with Curly?
Looked like he was gonna cry."
"It's about Terry, Hug.
Prudholm is finally going to be tried for her murder."
Huggy whistled. "Heavy."
"Yeah. We've been interviewing
witnesses all morning. I think he's about at the end of his rope."
"I bet he's refusin' to eat
again, but the Bear is on it anyhow. I'll whip up a Starsky special. See if
he'll give it try."
"Thanks, Huggy. I don't know
what we'd do without you, man."
When Starsky returned, Hutch could
tell he'd been crying and his heart nearly broke. His poor partner had suffered
so much over Terry. He hoped this was going to help. Starsky wearily climbed
onto a barstool next to Hutch.
"Where'd Huggy go?"
"He's in the kitchen whipping
up a Starsky special."
"Oh, Hutch, I can't eat
it."
"You should try. Wouldn't want
to hurt Huggy's feelings would ya?"
"Huggy'll understand."
"Yeah, he will, but please try
anyway."
"Okay."
Starsky managed to get in a few
bites of his lunch. At least Huggy was successful in getting him to drink a
couple of sodas. The extent of Starsky's contribution to their conversation was
nods and an occasional "Uh-huh." He was becoming withdrawn and Hutch
was worried.
As they got up to leave, Huggy put a
hand on Starsky's arm and gave it a little squeeze.
"Hang in there, my man."
"Thanks, Hug. I will."
The two men walked back out into the
afternoon sunlight, an excellent excuse for Starsky to pull on a pair of dark
sunglasses. He thought maybe he could hide behind them for a while.
"Time to go in and report on
these interviews, partner. You up for it?"
"Sure."
"You makin' it okay?"
"Yeah."
Hutch knew his best friend was in
trouble. He hadn't heard anything more eloquent than single syllable words and
grunts from Starsky in the past hour. After they filled out their reports and
talked to Dobey, Hutch would take Starsky home and stay with him. No way was he
going to leave his buddy alone tonight. Starsky hadn't looked this fragile or
this close to the edge in a long time.
Street parking near the precinct was
nonexistent in the afternoon and this day was no exception. They tried to avoid
parking in the precinct garage whenever possible. Both men had too many bad
memories of another day they had parked there. This time Hutch found a space he
could back the Torino into, leaving neither side totally exposed. Starsky gave
him a slight, but appreciative smile. The space was near the door to prisoner
intake and a van was just pulling into the drive in front of that door. The
side of the van said, "Caballo Point Psychiatric Hospital."
Hutch noticed it immediately. Damn. I hope that's not Prudholm. Dobey said hed be here tomorrow. Damn. He tried to turn his gaze elsewhere, preventing Starsky from
seeing what he had seen, but it was too late. Starsky had already seen the van.
They both watched as the door opened
and George Prudholm was led from the van in shackles.
Hutch watched Starsky carefully,
subconsciously positioning himself between his partner and Prudholm. He tried
hard to keep in the line of sight, so Prudholm could not make eye contact with
Starsky.
He watched as Starsky took off the
sunglasses and stared in pained silence at the man who shattered his life. When
he looked toward the van, he saw Prudholm stop abruptly and look their way. He
was looking directly at Starsky. Only twenty feet separated the two men.
Prudholm had a look of smug satisfaction on his face. The same one he had worn
the last day Hutch saw him as they carted him out of court and back to the
mental hospital.
Prudholm stopped and smiled his evil
smile at Starsky. He spoke.
"Hello, Starsky. Still
single?"
Hutch watched and heard Starsky
snap. He started toward Prudholm, rage playing out across his face. Hutch
quickly stepped closer and blocked him. He put his hands on either side of his
friend and struggled to keep him from reaching his target. Hutch turned and
yelled to a couple of uniforms standing in the doorway near Prudholm. "Get
him inside. Now!"
"Let me go, Hutch."
"No, Starsk. Let it be."
Thankfully, the other officers
quickly moved Prudholm inside and out of sight. Starsky stopped struggling
against his partner. The adrenaline rush and his feelings of grief had nowhere
to go. He started to shake uncontrollably and he dropped his sunglasses to the
ground, ignoring them as they shattered into as many pieces as his psyche.
Hutch pulled his best friend into a
hug.
"Let it go, babe. It'll be
okay. I'm right here."
He was afraid Starsky was going to
fall down, so Hutch kept one arm around his friend's shoulders as he led him
inside the back door to the precinct where he could sit down in the air
conditioned building and recover. He could not believe what Prudholm had said
to Starsky. The man was evil. He may never have been insane, but he had always
been evil.
Somehow Hutch got Starsky upstairs
without encountering too many other officers. Starsky's face had gone a pasty
gray color and Hutch was alarmed. As soon as the elevator doors opened, Starsky
jerked his arm away from Hutch and dashed down the hall to the men's room.
Hutch hurried after him and through the door just as Starsky went to his knees
in front of the nearest toilet.
There was nothing Hutch could do for
him until it was over, and by then he was waiting with a cool, wet handful of
paper towel. Wordlessly, he used it to wipe Starsky's sweaty face, running it
down the back of his neck, too.
Starsky sagged back into a sitting position,
with his back against the stall, too weak and spent to even stand, and let
Hutch take care of him.
Hutch tossed the towels toward the
trash without bothering to see if they went in. His eyes were filling, too.
"Can you stand up, buddy?" he asked gently.
Starsky mutely nodded, and Hutch
held out his hands to help him. When Starsky was upright, Hutch slid an arm
around his back. Starsky leaned against him as they went to the mercifully
empty squad room. The only occupant was a young officer typing a report, and he
never even raised his head as they came in and went to their own desk across
the room. Hutch got Starsky into a chair.
"I'll be right back," he
said, reaching into his pocket for change. He went back into the hall, to the
soda machine, and brought back a 7-Up. "Here," he said, setting it
down in front of Starsky. "Sip that, slowly. It'll settle you down."
Starsky obeyed, still without
speaking. And that worried Hutch more than anything else. He sat down in the
next chair, pulling it into a position that would allow his body to block the
sight of Starsky from the other officer and from anyone who happened to come
in. Starsky's face had regained a little color, but not enough, and his eyes
were rimmed with exhausted dark circles. Hutch forced down the lump in his own
throat and reached out with one hand to grasp his partner's hand. He slid the
other around Starsky's shoulders and gently stroked the curls at his collar.
Damn whoever might see them.
Starsky's hand wrapped around
Hutch's tightly and they sat there in silence for several minutes.
"Hutch," Starsky said
hoarsely at last, "I wanna go home."
"Sure, buddy. Let me tell
Dobey, okay? Will you be okay for a minute?"
Starsky nodded.
Hutch tapped once on Dobey's door
and opened it. Dobey was on the phone, but he waved Hutch in.
"What time are you doing the
interrogation?" Dobey asked. He nodded a couple of times. "All right.
I'll inform them...damned right they're going to be there! They're the
arresting officers, as you'd know if you'd read the report!" He glared at
the phone briefly, then relaxed. "No, that's probably a good idea. I doubt
if Starsky wants to be in the same room with him, anyway. All right, Mark. See
you tomorrow." He hung up and looked at Hutch. "They're questioning
Prudholm tomorrow. He's already demanded his lawyer, so I doubt if he has much
to say. I've arranged for you and Starsky to observe."
Hutch glanced over his shoulder and
reached out to push the door closed. "Captain, I don't know if that's a
good idea."
Dobey raised his eyebrows and
glanced toward the door, too. "How bad is he?"
Hutch shook his head and wet his
lips. "Pretty bad."
Dobey sighed. "I guess I
thought after three years, it wouldn't hurt so much."
"He loved her, Captain."
"Yeah, I know," Dobey
said. "Take him home, Hutch. The interrogation isn't until ten. Don't
bother coming in until then. Let him sleep late and maybe he'll feel a little
better."
Hutch doubted that, and he also
doubted Starsky would get much sleep, but he nodded. "Thanks." He
rose to go, but Dobey motioned to him.
"Hutch," he paused.
"One of you has to be there tomorrow. Can you handle it?"
Hutch nodded. "I'll take care
of it. But you know Starsky. He'll probably insist on being there, too."
He considered for a moment. "Don't let on to Prudholm he's there, and
maybe he won't say anything to hurt him." He repeated for Dobey what had
happened outside.
Dobey visibly blanched at Prudholm's
remark to Starsky. "God," he said and was silent for several beats.
"I'll tell Mark," he said. "Prudholm won't know."
"Thanks." Hutch went back
out to the squad room and found his partner in exactly the same position he'd
left him. His heart twisted at Starsky's defeated posture. "Hey, buddy.
Let's go home, huh?"
Starsky nodded and stood, swaying a
little. Hutch put his arm around him again and led him through the double
doors.
There was no question who would
drive. Hutch loaded Starsky into the passenger side of the Torino and drove to
Starsky's place. When they got there, he helped Starsky up the stairs and as
far as the couch. Through it all, Starsky never uttered a word. The photographs
he'd been looking at the night before were still scattered over the coffee
table, and Hutch briefly considered picking them up and putting them away, but
he saw Starsky's eyes feasting on them hungrily, even though he didn't reach
for any of them, and he thought better of it. Instead, he tossed his jacket on
a chair.
"Want something to drink?"
Starsky shook his head, so Hutch
went into the kitchen and got a glass of ice water for himself, a big glass.
Maybe Starsky would manage to keep a few swallows down. He came back, set the
glass where Starsky could reach it, and sat beside him.
"What can I do, buddy?" he
asked.
"Nothin'," Starsky said.
"It's just gotta be got through is all." His eyes were too bright,
and he slid out of his jacket. "I'm gonna take a shower."
"Okay," Hutch said,
watching as Starsky rose, slowly and painfully, like a much older man, and went
toward his bedroom. He kept his own composure long enough for the bathroom door
to close behind his partner, then allowed his own tears to fall.
Starsky was in the bathroom a long
time, long enough for Hutch to get his own sorrow back under control and to
start worrying about him. But the water shut off at last and Hutch drew a deep
breath. He had to be strong enough to support Starsky. It wasn't going to do
either of them any good for Hutch to crumble. As hard as the last couple of
days had been, the next days were going to be one hell of a lot worse.
He looked a little better after the
shower. Still tired and sad, but a little more relaxed. No, not relaxed, more
like drained.
"Hey, buddy. Feeling any
better?"
Starsky just shrugged his shoulders
as he sat down on the couch.
"Don't suppose you want
anything to eat."
This time he only shook his head.
Hutch was so worried. Seeing his best friend withdraw like this was not a good
sign.
"I think I'll order some
Chinese food. Maybe you'll feel like it later."
Starsky looked at him and sighed. As
if preparing to say his next sentence was going to take every bit of remaining
energy he had.
"Look, Hutch. I'm not gonna be
very good company tonight. Why don't you just go on home, huh?"
"I think I'd rather just crash
here tonight, Gordo."
"No need. I'll be okay."
"I know you will, buddy. Still,
I'd rather stay."
Starsky looked at him with a mixture
of profound sadness and gratitude, his eyes conveying the message of thanks.
"I'm sorry I lost it,
Hutch."
"You don't have anything to be
sorry about, Starsk. What he said to you . . . ."
"Don't."
"I'm sorry, Starsk. It just
makes me so angry!" Hutch stood up and paced around the apartment
attempting to disperse his rage over what Prudholm had said to Starsky.
"Seeing him like that, I just .
. . lost it."
"You going to be able to do
this?"
"Have to, Hutch. For
Terry."
"For you, too, pal."
Starsky nodded. "What's next,
Hutch? Why'd they bring him down today?"
Hutch was dreading telling his
partner about the interrogation. He knew Starsky would want to be there and he
was concerned about what it would do to him.
"Um, uh, interrogation
t-tomorrow."
Starsky smiled just a little. Poor
Hutch tended to stammer when he was upset about something, especially if it had
to do with Starsky.
"When."
"You don't have to be
there."
"Yes, I do."
"N-No, I can handle it."
"You're hurting, too,
Hutch."
Starsky didn't miss much where Hutch
was concerned. He didn't attempt to deny it.
"I know. Please, let me do it
alone."
"Nope"
Resigned, Hutch answered his
question. "Ten. Dobey said not to come in before then."
Starsky nodded his understanding and
slowly stood. "Okay, partner. WE'LL be there."
"You going to bed?"
"Yeah. Night."
Hutch watched him walk dejectedly
toward his bedroom. Please let him at least sleep well.
Several hours later, Hutch was
jolted awake by the sound of Starsky yelling Terry's name in his sleep. Before
he could get up off the couch and go in to wake Starsky up, he saw him come
running out of his bedroom and into the bathroom. Hutch followed him in there
and stood by helplessly while Starsky heaved again. He hadn't eaten anything,
so there wasn't much for him to lose.
When he was finally back in control,
Hutch sat next to him on the bathroom floor, handing him a glass of water and
wiping his face just like he had done in the afternoon.
Starsky was breathing hard, almost
hyperventilating.
"Oh, God, Hutch!"
"Sh, I'm here, buddy"
"How'm I gonna do this?"
"You can do it. I'll be there
with you."
They had nothing left to say. Starsky
sat on the floor, quiet tears streaming down his face. All Hutch could do was
offer his shoulder in comfort. That was how they spent the rest of the night.
Starsky was finally exhausted enough to sleep a little bit around dawn. Hutch
let him sleep as long as he could, then woke him around nine to get ready for
their trip into the precinct. He knew this part of the journey was going to be
difficult.
Starsky was composed when they
reached the precinct. Hutch still hadn't gotten him to eat anything, but at
least he didn't seem sick anymore. Hutch was worried about the almost blank
look on his face. He didn't like the thought that Starsky was checked out
instead of feeling, even if those feelings would hurt like hell.
They paused at the observation room door,
Hutch putting his hand on Starsky's shoulder and turning him around gently.
"You sure you want to do
this?"
Starsky nodded the affirmative.
They walked into the room and closed
the door behind them. Positioning himself in a chair in front of the observation
mirror, Starsky steeled himself for whatever was about to happen. Captain Dobey
walked in right after they did, stopping to pat Starsky reassuringly on the
shoulder before he moved to a chair in the corner of the room.
Within a few minutes, the District
Attorney walked into the room accompanied by James Olin, Prudholm's attorney.
Olin shook hands with the D.A. and they took their seats.
"Any chance we can do a plea
bargain, Johnson?"
Starsky stiffened in his chair and
Hutch placed a hand on his forearm reassuringly.
"You must be joking, Olin.
Murder one, all the way."
Starsky relaxed a little.
"You'll never get it. He was
insane."
"You know, Olin, I doubt that.
What he did was calculating and cold. He pursued that poor woman like a wolf
after its prey. He lay in wait for her. That's a death penalty pop as far as my
office is concerned."
Hutch was watching Starsky
carefully, ready to intervene if necessary. So far, he looked all right, but
Prudholm hadn't appeared yet.
As if on cue to Hutch's thoughts,
George Prudholm was escorted into the room by two uniforms. He was seated in a
chair. One of the uniforms stood in the corner of the interrogation room and
the other left to stand outside the door.
Starsky leaned forward, his forearms
on his knees and his hands clenched into tight fists. He was pale, and his
focus was riveted on the man who killed the love of his life.
The D.A. began, "George
Prudholm, you are about to go on trial for the murder of Terry Roberts. Do you
understand the charges?"
"Yeah, I understand."
"You should know that the
District Attorney's office also intends to prosecute you for the attempted
murder of police detectives Starsky and Hutchinson, and for holding two
innocent women hostage at gunpoint before you were apprehended. Those charges
will be levied against you in a separate trial."
"I never tried to kill those
two. If I had, they'd be dead!"
Olin turned to Prudholm and advised
him to be quiet about that
"I was under the impression you
had attempted to blow at least Detective Hutchinson away with a rigged
shotgun."
"All right, Johnson, let's
stick to the current charges."
Prudholm pasted an evil smile on his
face. He said nothing else. Hutch looked at him and started to worry that the
man might know he and his partner were watching. Prudholm was looking past his
attorney, right at the mirror. Hutch looked back to Starsky. He was beginning
to shake. Hutch quietly moved his chair closer to Starsky and put an arm around
his shoulders. The trembling he felt scared him. He couldn't help wondering how
much more Starsky could take.
Johnson continued. "You know if
you plead guilty, you won't get the gas chamber."
"Go to hell. I'm not pleading
guilty. For what? Wiping some stupid chick off the face of the Earth? Who
cares."
Starsky was starting to sweat and
the shaking was getting worse. Hutch was afraid he was going to get sick again.
Prudholm continued to look at the
mirror with increasing intensity.
"Prudholm! You don't have to
answer him. This isn't a courtroom."
"Shut up."
Johnson said, "Prudholm, I just
want to know one thing from you. Why."
"Don't answer that!"
"I said shut up! I'll tell you
why"
Prudholm paused and looked at the
mirror directly at where Starsky sat. If Hutch didn't know better, he would
have thought the man could see them.
"I wanted to hurt Starsky. He
killed my son. I wanted to destroy his life just like he did mine. I only wish
I'd succeeded in blowing away his precious partner. Right in front of him,
that's what I wanted."
Olin jumped up and said, "That's
it, this interview is over." Prudholm had one more thing to say, though.
"If I had to do it again, the
only thing I'd change is making it more painful. I shoulda messed her up first.
Starsky's little slut died too easy. I shoulda made him watch me do her, then
killed both of 'em."
"Prudholm!" Starsky
roared, coming out of his chair and throwing himself at the glass so quickly
that Hutch couldn't move fast enough to stop him. He shot out of his chair
right behind Starsky, however, and grabbed his partner's shoulders. The room
was soundproof; there was no way Prudholm could have heard Starsky, but the way
the man was staring fixedly at the mirror, with that cold glitter in his eyes
and a self-satisfied grin on his face, Hutch could have sworn he HAD heard.
"Whatsa matter, Starsky?"
Prudholm said clearly, his eyes boring right into Starsky's. "You want a
piece of me? You had your chance in that grocery warehouse."
Starsky was trembling so violently
that his shaking shook Hutch, too, and his fists were white-knuckled.
"Easy, buddy, easy," Hutch
said desperately. "He's trying to get to you. He wants to make you crazy.
Don't let him, Starsk. Don't let him!"
Starsky drew back his hand to strike
the mirror, but Hutch grabbed it and braced himself. After several tense
moments, Starsky relaxed, marginally. And Hutch gently pushed him until he
backed away from the window.
"I thought we agreed Prudholm
wouldn't know he was here!" Hutch barked at Dobey, who had watched the
whole thing in stunned silence.
"We didn't tell him,"
Dobey said defensively.
"Nobody had to," Starsky
said, his voice tight. "He just knew. Where else would I be?"
In the interrogation room, Olin was
sweating. "George, come on. Don't say any more. Let's go."
"We'll see you in court,"
Johnson said coldly. "Get him out of here."
The uniformed officers escorted
Prudholm away and Starsky sagged against Hutch. Hutch backed him into his chair
and knelt beside it.
Starsky closed his eyes and drew a
deep breath. His face had gone that pasty gray color again and Hutch could
actually see the pulse pounding in his throat.
There was a knock on the door and
Johnson poked his head through, took in the scene, and came the rest of the way
in, closing the door behind him. "I'm sorry, Sergeant," he said to
Starsky. "We didn't tell him you were here, but he must've guessed."
Starsky opened his eyes and though
they glittered with emotion, he nodded. "'S okay, Counselor."
Johnson shifted his weight
uncertainly. "I'll be in touch to go over your testimony. We go to trial
on Thursday."
Starsky nodded, and Hutch squeezed
his arm gently.
Johnson stood there another moment,
then with a glance at Dobey, he said, "Uh, well, I'll give you a
call." He left.
"Starsky," Dobey said
quietly, "I'm giving the two of you the rest of the day off." He
raised a hand when Starsky opened his mouth. "Don't argue with me. Go
home. Go fishing. Go somewhere else. I don't want you here, and you don't need
to be here. This trial is important. I want you to be able to handle it."
His voice softened. "Please, Dave. You've been through enough."
Starsky dropped his eyes and nodded.
"Okay, Cap. Thanks."
Dobey stood and patted his shoulder.
He left the room.
"Didja hear that?" Starsky
said, his voice shaking, but vainly attempting a light touch anyway. "He
called me 'Dave.'"
Hutch smiled in spite of himself.
"I heard. You always were his favorite."
Starsky tried to smile back, but his
eyes were filling and he closed them again.
Aw, buddy. Hutch felt the lump rise in his throat and tried
to choke it down. "Come on. I'm taking you to Waffle House and you're
going to eat."
"No, please," Starsky
said, reaching out to touch Hutch's hair. "Let's go home, huh? I got bacon
and eggs and stuff. I can't I don't want nobody to see me right now."
Hutch nodded.
When they got to Starsky's, Starsky
started for the kitchen as soon as he'd taken his jacket off.
"I'll do it, buddy," Hutch
said. "You sit down. You haven't eaten anything and you look like
hell."
"I need to be doin'
something," Starsky said. "I can't just sit."
Hutch bit his lip, but let him. He
sat on the couch and listened to the sounds of Starsky cooking, and his eyes
fell on the scattered photographs. He picked up a handful and went through
them. Mostly they were just snapshots.
But one in particular made Hutch
freeze when he found it. Terry was leaning against a tree, the sunlight dappled
on her hair and shoulders as it fell through the leaves over her head. Starsky
stood next to her, looking at her instead of the camera, one hand resting
casually at her waist. Both were beaming. They looked so happy....
For some reason, it was just too
much. The tension of the last couple of days, the strain of trying to be strong
for Starsky when his own heart was aching, all spilled over and the photograph
blurred before his eyes. He covered his face with one hand and tried to get a
grip.
"Hey." The couch shifted
as Starsky sat beside him and Hutch struggled for control. Starsky's arm went
around his shoulders as Starsky pulled Hutch's head against his shoulder.
"Let it out, boy," Starsky said hoarsely, his voice thick with
emotion. "Get it over with. And quit tryin' to be so tough. I know you're
hurtin', too."
Hutch sat and cried with his best
friend. He cried for Terry, for Starsky, and for himself. "Starsk,"
he managed to squeak out, "I loved her, too."
"I know, buddy, I know. Just
get it all out." Suddenly, Starsky was the strong one. Offering comfort to
Hutch when his own reserves where empty. That was the way of their
relationship. Give and take, comforting and comforted, Me and Thee. They sat
together like that for long minutes, neither man saying anything. Finally,
Hutch sat back from Starsky's shoulder and looked at him, his eyes red rimmed
and still wet with tears.
"I know how much he hurt you.
Nobody knows better than me." He sniffed and took a deep, shuddering
breath before continuing. "I can't stand to hear that turkey say those
things about Terry. Worse than what he says, Starsk, I hate what it's doing to
you. Terry can't be hurt anymore, but you can. "
"I'm gonna make it through,
Hutch. He ain't gonna get me, buddy. He's just a sicko."
Who was Starsky trying to kid?
Himself? Hutch? Neither one of them was buying it.
"That's just it, Starsk. I'm
not so sure. The man may not be a regular sicko. Buddy, I think he's just evil.
He's evil and I don't want you anywhere near him."
"Ah, Hutch, you know I have to
be at the trial."
"Yeah, as a witness. You don't
have to sit there through the whole thing."
"Yes, I do."
Hutch took both of Starsky's hands
in his and looked him in the eyes. He prayed his friend couldn't resist the
look he was giving him. "Please, Starsk. Let me go alone. Don't be there
every day."
Starsky looked away from Hutch
knowing that another moment looking into Hutch's pleading eyes and he might
waver. He couldn't do that, though. He closed his eyes and shook his head.
"No, Hutch. Don't ask me that. You know I have to do it. For Terry and for
me."
Hutch dropped his eyes to the floor
and his shoulders slumped. He said almost too quietly for his partner to hear,
"I know, Gordo. I just want to protect you any way I can."
Starsky needed to change the
subject, "Hey, can I leave you alone for a minute? I'm supposed to be
fixing you something to eat."
"You're supposed to be fixing
US something to eat."
"You've got me there,
partner." Starsky smiled, patted Hutch on the shoulder and headed for the
kitchen.
Hutch did manage to coax Starsky
into eating half of what was on his plate. Then he prayed his friend would be
able to hold onto it. Having pulled himself back together, he had moved back
into protective mode and was thinking about how he was going to keep Starsky's
mind off of things for the rest of the day. Though he had to twist Starsky's
arm, he talked him into going to the movies, then for a long walk on the beach.
Hutch was hoping to tire him out a little so he could get a better night's
sleep. Then they went over to Hutch's place to pick some things up for him.
They both knew Hutch would be spending the night again.
Over at Hutch's apartment, Starsky
had gone down to the corner market to pick up a six-pack for them while Hutch
watered his plants. Captain Dobey called while Starsky was gone.
"I hoped I'd catch you there.
Can you talk?"
"Yeah, he went to the store for
a few minutes. You have something?"
"Yeah. Is he any better?"
"Better than this morning. He's
a little less withdrawn. We went to the movies and the beach. I think he's
getting tired."
"Good. He's going to need his
strength. The jury is seated. D.A. Johnson wants to talk to both of you. I
don't want Starsky down here again until Thursday at the trial. Can I tell
Johnson to go to Starsky's house tomorrow to talk to you?"
"Yeah, Cap. Good thinking. I
tried to talk him out of sitting in on the trial."
"Snowball's chance in hell,
huh?"
"Uh-huh."
"Keep an eye on him, Hutch. I
didn't like what I saw in his eyes this afternoon. Can't say I blame him,
though. Prudholm really hurt him today."
"Yeah, he did."
"I'll tell Johnson to stop by
Starsky's place at two tomorrow. Okay?"
"Great. If he has another rough
night, maybe he can sleep through the morning."
Hutch heard Starsky approaching the
front door. "He's back, Cap."
"Call me if you need me."
"Thanks."
Hutch hung up the phone just as
Starsky was walking into the living room.
"Dobey?"
"Yeah. The D.A. is coming over
to your place at two tomorrow. The jury is seated and they're ready to start
day after tomorrow."
Starsky nodded. "You done
watering your jungle?"
"Yep. Let's go on back over to
your place. We can watch the game."
"Sounds good, Blondie. Lead the
way."
Hutch was glad to hear a little
lightness back in Starsky's voice. Maybe another day away from the case and all
of its implications would give him the strength he needed.
Back at Starsky's, the evening
passed uneventfully. They watched the game and finished that six-pack over the
next few hours. Starsky was still pale, but he had kept the food down and
seemed a little better. He disappeared for another long shower, worrying Hutch,
but when he came out, he still looked all right.
Taking his turn in the bathroom,
Hutch was upset to find a bottle of sleeping pills sitting on the counter. For
a fleeting moment, he felt a sense of panic. He actually opened the bottle and
started to count the pills before shaking his head. Geez, Hutchinson, get a
grip already. Still....
He went into the kitchen where
Starsky was drinking a glass of chocolate milk and said, "Starsk, what's
with the sleeping pills?"
"Relax, buddy. You know I hate
those things but I really need to be able to sleep tonight. I don't want to
dream either, know what I mean?"
"You shouldn't take those when
you've been drinking."
"I know, Mom. I only took one,
so chill. I'm okay."
Starsky was both annoyed and touched
by Hutch's concern. The man didn't miss a thing. Next time he wouldn't forget
to put the bottle back in the medicine cabinet.
The sleeping pill worked. Starsky
slept through the night and never stirred. Hutch was grateful he hadn't needed to
help his friend through another nightmare. Starsky needed the sleep. On the
other hand, Hutch had a rough night. His restless sleep was interrupted by a
series of bad dreams. The dreams were about Terry's death, and worse than that,
Starsky's. Adding to his restlessness, the couch was not comfortable. Two
nights on it in a row had Hutch's back as stiff as it had been in a long time.
He made himself a silent promise to save enough money to buy Starsky a sofa bed
for his birthday.
Hutch got up early and peeked in on
Starsky. He was still sound asleep, so Hutch went out for his run. He brought
bagels back for breakfast, then took a shower. Starsky still wasn't awake by
the time the coffee was made and Hutch had no intention of waking him. He slept
until ten.
"Hey, Hutch! Why'd ya let me
sleep so late?"
Hutch looked up from the newspaper
he was reading. "If you slept late, you needed it."
He smiled. His friend was looking a
little better.
Starsky shuffled into the kitchen to
get some coffee. "Hey, bagels! Thanks, buddy. You already eat?"
"Nope. Waitin' for you. You
hungry, partner?"
"A little. Thanks for the
bagels. You make chicken soup, too?"
They ate their breakfast and
puttered around the apartment for the next four hours waiting for the D.A.
Starsky was looking stronger and Hutch was wishing he didn't have to go through
the next several days. He'd take Starsky over to Huggy's for a good dinner in
case it was the last one he got his partner to eat for the next few days.
Mark Johnson was on time. The three men
sat at the kitchen table, drinking coffee and discussing the trial. Hutch kept
a wary eye on his partner.
"First, let's talk about your
testimony. You'll both be called to the stand. Hutch, you will testify as an
arresting officer and a witness to what happened to Terry. Starsky, you will
also testify as an arresting officer, as a witness, and as Terry's fiancι. I
want you to talk about what he did to you."
Hutch intervened, "Is that
necessary?"
"Only if you want a
conviction."
Starsky's jaw was set. "I can
do it."
"Good, I also want you to
testify about any conversations you had with him and how he wanted to hurt you
because of the death of his son."
Again, Starsky nodded.
"When are you going to call
him?"
"Last thing on Thursday. I want
the jury to have him in their minds when we close for the day. He will probably
still be on the stand Friday morning, though."
Starsky got up to get some more
coffee. Hutch knew he was trying to maintain his balance.
"I think you should know a few
other things. Starsky, I want you in the courtroom every day. Whenever anyone
is testifying, I want you right out front for the jury to see."
"Sounds like you're planning to
use him for effect!" Hutch was angry.
"I am. I know that sounds
terrible, but you want him to go down, don't you?"
"Yes."
The lawyer looked at him, knowing
how hard this was going to be. "I'm sorry, Hutch. This is going to be
difficult. Starsky, you need to keep your composure and it's not going to be
easy."
"I know, I know." He was
losing his patience.
"All right. We are going to
show some home movies of Terry that were made at the school. Also, I want you
to be prepared for their witnesses."
Starsky swallowed and looked
distressed at the prospect of watching movies of Terry. Hutch put a hand on his
arm and looked at him in support.
"They are going to call in a
psychiatrist to show that Prudholm is sick. They have also subpoenaed Lonnie
Craig's mother as a hostile witness."
"What!" Hutch was furious.
"Why?" Starsky had killed Lonnie Craig in self-defense following a
hold up and Prudholm had blamed him for it. He related Lonnie's death to his
own son's death.
"They probably want to show
what it feels like to love someone that Starsky has destroyed."
"That stinks! "
"I know, that's why she's a hostile
witness. They are also going to call Prudholm's partner, Woody the Magic Man.
Then there is a list of witnesses from Caballo Point. Finally, they will
probably have Prudholm on the stand. I know Olin doesn't want him to testify,
but he is insisting. Even though it's good for us, having him up there will
give him the chance to say things you might not want to hear."
"Okay, enough. What time do I
have to be there tomorrow?"
"I want you there first thing,
that's at nine."
They spent the next two hours going
over the questions and their testimony. Starsky was already looking edgy. Hutch
knew he was going to have a hard time keeping his partner together through this
trial. He had no more time to feel bad himself, he had to be strong for
Starsky.
~*~*~*~
"How do I look?" Starsky
asked as they climbed the courthouse steps.
"You look fine," Hutch
said, patting his back. "Question is, how do you feel?"
"I'll make it," Starsky
said with grim determination.
The courtroom was crowded. The story
in yesterday's paper recapping the case and making a big point of Starsky's
relationship with Terry had probably drawn out the ghouls. Starsky kept his
eyes focused straight ahead as they walked in and went to the seats Johnson
waved them to, behind the prosecution's table.
"How're you doing,
Sergeant?"
"Fine," Starsky said
shortly.
"Okay. Just checking."
Johnson turned back to his notes.
A few minutes later, the guards
brought Prudholm into the courtroom. They seated him next to his lawyer and
Olin leaned over to confer with him, but Prudholm's eyes were fixed on Starsky
and he impatiently waved his lawyer away.
"All rise."
The judge came through the chamber
door and sat down. There was a rustle as the gallery seated themselves.
"Court is now in session. The
honorable Judge Joseph Greanias presiding."
Greanias shuffled the papers in
front of him and looked at Prudholm. "George Prudholm, you stand accused
of the murder of Teresa Renee Roberts. You have pleaded not guilty by reason of
insanity. Does that plea stand?"
"It does, your honor,"
Olin said, rising.
"Mr. Johnson, you may commence
your opening statement."
Johnson rose and approached the jury
box. "Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. We are here today because the
State is confident we can prove this man," he indicated Prudholm,
"murdered Miss Roberts in cold blood as an act of revenge against her
fiancι, Detective Sergeant David Starsky. Miss Roberts was 28 years old at the
time of her death. She taught developmentally disabled children. She was
engaged to be married to Sergeant Starsky. And she was struck down in the prime
of her life because this man," he turned toward Prudholm, "had a
vendetta against her fiancι, one of Bay City's finest officers, who has earned
several commendations for bravery and devotion to duty, and who almost lost his
life last year in the line of duty."
Starsky flinched. He hadn't known
Johnson was going to bring that up. Hutch put a hand on his arm but didn't dare
do more.
"Ladies and gentlemen, you have
the power to make this man pay for his crime. I have faith in your
integrity." Johnson sat down.
"Mr. Olin, your opening
statement?"
Olin rose and gave Johnson a look as
he approached the jury in his turn. "My client is not guilty," he
said to them. "Yes, he pulled the trigger. We do not dispute that fact.
But my client suffers from a psychotic disorder for which he has been in
residential treatment for the last three years, and in and out of treatment for
many years prior to that. He cannot be held responsible for his crime."
After Olin sat down, Greanias told
Johnson he could call his first witness.
He began with the clerk from the
all-night store, who told about the robbery and how Prudholm and Woody the
Magic Man had made a point of shooting Terry, and hadn't even been interested
in stealing any money.
Olin objected several times,
insisting that the man was relating his perception rather than facts, but the
judge allowed the testimony. When Olin cross-examined, he made a point of the
fact that Prudholm and Woody had taken what was in the register, though Woody
had had to remind Prudholm to do it.
Then Johnson called Captain Dobey to
the stand.
"Captain, how long have you
been on the force?"
"Almost 30 years," Dobey
said.
"You are Sergeant Starsky's
superior officer, is that correct?"
"Yes," Dobey said.
"I've been his captain for nine years."
"Tell us about the Lonnie Craig
incident, please."
"Starsky and Hutchinson and
several other officers answered a call on an armed robbery at a small liquor
store. There was a lot of shooting and one of the uniformed officers was hit in
the shoulder. When the suspects ran, Starsky and Hutchinson gave chase. Starsky
fired two warning shots and shouted at Craig to halt, but Craig turned around
and brought his gun down to fire. Starsky shot and killed him. Some of the
witnesses believed Craig
"Objection!" Olin stood.
"Was this witness present for this incident?"
"Your honor, there was a public
hearing, broadcast on local television, in which all these facts were
mentioned," Johnson said.
"I'll allow it," Greanias
said. "But I must instruct the jury that the witness is repeating
testimony from a prior legal proceeding, not facts he knows of his own
knowledge."
"Continue, Captain."
"Some of the witnesses believed
Craig was trying to surrender and accused Starsky of overstepping the bounds of
reasonable force," Dobey said, with a glance at Starsky. "There was a
hearing. The most vocal of these witnesses recanted at the hearing and admitted
that he was mistaken, that he now believes Craig was going to shoot Starsky and
that Starsky had no other option but to shoot first. I was present for this
hearing," Dobey added.
"And then what?"
"During the hearing, George
Prudholm called headquarters and threatened that if Starsky was found innocent
of wrongdoing, he'd 'make us pay and pay bad,'" Dobey said. "We have
recordings of all his calls."
"Did you know who he was
then?"
"No," Dobey said.
"But soon after the hearing ended, an officer was shot answering a false
call, and a rifle was left behind with a note on it that said, 'For Starsky.'
Then Prudholm called again and said if Starsky didn't resign, and release that
fact to the press, he would kill another officer."
"And Starsky did not
resign?"
"No." Dobey said. "I
talked him out of it. He wanted to."
"Continue, please."
"The next day, another officer
was killed by a bomb planted in a gas station restroom, again answering a false
call that a baby had been left there. Prudholm called again and demanded
Starsky's resignation again. We figured out who he was from some of the things
he said on the phone, and Starsky and Hutchinson went to his apartment to
attempt to apprehend him. He called them there and instructed Starsky to meet
him at the old city zoo, alone, or he'd kill an officer's family next. Starsky
agreed, but Hutchinson followed him there, against Prudholm's instructions, and
Prudholm ambushed him. Starsky fired back and hit him in the shoulder, and he
and Hutchinson arrested him."
"Prudholm clearly said on these
tapes that he was killing officers in retaliation for Starsky shooting Lonnie
Craig?"
"Yes."
"Nothing further, your
honor."
Olin rose. "Wasn't my client
prosecuted for these killings, Captain?"
"Yes, he was."
"And what was his
sentence?"
Dobey was clearly angry. "He
was sent to Caballo Point Psychiatric Hospital for an undetermined amount of
time."
"In other words, the court
found him to be incompetent to stand trial?"
"Yes," Dobey snapped.
"Nothing further, your
honor."
Next, Johnson called Mrs. Rachman, who
talked about how valuable Terry was to the school for exceptional children, how
she was personally responsible for Sally's great improvement and how she had
started the intramural basketball league that had done so much for the
children's social and physical health.
Getty followed and repeated many of
the same things. Olin refused to cross-examine either of them, and questioned
the purpose of their testimony. Johnson retorted that he was showing that
Prudholm could not possibly have known or had any reason to harm Terry.
Then it was time for the home movies
of Terry and the kids.
Starsky paled visibly as the
projector was brought out.
Hutch unobtrusively slid a hand
under his arm and held on tight.
The movies showed Terry teaching,
playing with the kids, patiently working over and over to get one small boy to
learn to write his name...and some footage of one of the basketball games,
which included shots of Starsky and Hutch playing with the children.
Hutch glanced anxiously at Starsky
several times and Starsky remained composed, though the pallor of his face was
alarming. By the time the basketball game footage was playing, there were tears
standing in Starsky's eyes, though he managed not to let any of them fall.
Hutch struggled to remain as composed as his partner was. If Starsky could do
it, so could he.
The next witness was Dr. Quo.
"You are a neurosurgeon at
Memorial Hospital, is that correct?" Johnson asked.
"Yes, it is," she
answered.
"And you were Miss Roberts'
doctor after she was shot?"
"Yes, I was."
"Please describe her
injuries."
With a sympathetic look at Starsky,
Dr. Quo said, "She suffered a bullet wound to the upper left quadrant of
her brain. The bullet lodged in the frontal lobe in such a way that surgery
would have meant certain death. Our only option was to leave the bullet in
place, with the risk that if it moved, she would die. Her prognosis for
survival was grim at best. If she had remained immobile, she might have
survived for several months to a year. By getting up and moving around, she ran
the risk of hastening her death. In any case, she couldn't have survived more
than a year."
"Did she understand the risk of
moving around?"
"Yes, she did. I explained it
to her myself. We also sought a second opinion from one of the leading neurosurgeons
in the country, a colleague of mine in New York City. He concurred with my
opinion, and Terry was aware of his findings."
"How is it that this injury did
not immediately kill Miss Roberts? Could that have been deliberate?"
"Objection!" Olin rose.
"I'll strike the second
question, your honor," Johnson said. "Please answer only the first
question, doctor."
"The bullet turned as it
entered her brain," Dr. Quo said. "If it had gone straight in, it
would have killed her instantly."
"Dr. Quo," Olin said in
his cross-examination, "couldn't we say that Miss Roberts is in some way
responsible for her own death? If she had taken your advice to remain immobile
she would have lived longer?"
"Objection!" Johnson said.
"Miss Roberts did not shoot herself. It was the bullet that killed her,
not her own actions."
The judge considered, and Starsky,
who had clenched his fists at Olin's question, visibly took himself under
control. "I'll allow it," Greanias said at last. "But only if
you rephrase the question, counselor."
Olin frowned, but nodded. "If
Miss Roberts had taken your advice, would her life have reasonably been
longer?"
Dr. Quo shook her head. "The
bullet could have moved at any time," she said. "Remaining immobile
would not necessarily have changed the ultimate outcome. Simply turning over in
bed, or sneezing, could have caused it to move. And the slightest movement
would be enough to kill her."
Hutch glanced at Starsky. That
settled one question that he knew had eaten at Starsky ever since Terry's
death. She had refused to remain in bed because she wanted to spend as much
time as possible with him. He had, in a way, blamed himself that she hadn't
stayed in the hospital. But Dr. Quo seemed quite definite. It wouldn't have
mattered that much.
Johnson questioned the doctor on
redirect once more before dismissing her. "How did Miss Roberts handle her
condition, doctor?"
Dr. Quo smiled very gently.
"Terry was a very strong young woman. She never shed a tear while I told her
about her condition. And she made me promise to break it gently to David. That
was the one thing she said she couldn't do herself."
Starsky swallowed hard.
"How did David react when you
told him about Terry's condition?" Johnson asked.
"I had to tell him twice,"
Dr. Quo said. "He was quite naturally stunned and upset. It was as if he
couldn't quite take it in." She glanced at Starsky again. "When it
did sink in, he cried."
A tear slid out of Starsky's eye and
started to fall, but he brushed it away hurriedly and composed himself again.
Johnson also glanced at him. "How long was it after the shooting before
her death?"
"About three weeks," Dr.
Quo said.
"So for three weeks Miss
Roberts, Sergeant Starsky and everyone who knew them had to live with the constant
knowledge that she could die at any time?"
Dr. Quo nodded. "That is
correct."
"Could you tell us about her
death, doctor?"
Starsky reached over and grasped
Hutch's hand in an almost-painful grip, but his eyes did not leave Dr. Quo's
face and his expression didn't change.
"She lost her sight
temporarily," Dr. Quo said. "That was the first sign that the end was
near. David brought her to the hospital, and she slipped into unconsciousness
for about three hours. At that point, it was quite possible that she would
never awaken. She did, however, and her sight came and went after that. The
bullet, you see, had moved so that it pressed against the optic nerve."
When she didn't continue, Johnson
gently prodded her to go on.
Dr. Quo drew a breath. "She was
very weak by then, but also insistent that I allow David to see her. I prepared
him as best as I could, and he went into her room. About 20 minutes later, his
partner arrived. About five minutes after that, David came out of her room and
told us she was dead."
"Do you remember his exact
words, doctor?"
She nodded and cast another glance
at Starsky. "He said, 'Hutch, she's gone.'"
The judge called for a brief recess
then, and the courtroom emptied. Starsky remained where he was until everyone
else was gone, and Johnson turned to him.
"You're next, Sergeant."
Starsky nodded.
"You're doing fine so
far," Johnson added, his voice softening. "I know this is hard for
you. I'm going to have to ask you some painful questions. Are you sure you're
up to it?"
He nodded again. "I'll be
okay."
He didn't look "okay" to
Hutch. As Johnson turned back to the table to go over his notes, Hutch nudged
his partner. "Come on, buddy. Let's find you something to drink and
stretch our legs a bit."
Starsky rose and followed him, right
into a crowd of reporters with cameras and tape recorders, all shouting
questions at him. The din was deafening.
But Hutch wrapped his arm around his
partner and forced his way through the group, shouting, "No comment!"
until he got Starsky past them and into the witnesses' room. Starsky sank into
a chair, ashen-faced.
"I forgot about the
reporters," he said bleakly.
"Me, too, buddy. I'm sorry. I'm
gonna call Dobey and tell him we need some guards down here."
But Starsky shook his head.
"No, don't. They're just doin' their jobs, Hutch. It ain't their
fault."
Hutch regarded him soberly for a
moment and finally nodded. "Okay. What do you want? Coke?"
"I don't know if I'd better
drink anything at all."
"You have to, buddy. We've been
in there for hours and you've got to testify next. I'll get you 7-Up."
Hutch left and found a soda machine down the hall. He came back with a can of
7-Up and handed it to his partner.
Starsky looked at it without
enthusiasm but took a couple of small sips. "I hate 7-Up," he said, with
just a shadow of a grin.
Hutch smiled back. "Better for
you than Coke, buddy. You don't need the caffeine." He picked up Starsky's
left arm and looked at his watch. "It's almost time." He reached over
to open the door.
"Hutch?"
"Yeah?" Hutch turned, his
hand still on the knob.
"Stay where I can see ya,
huh?"
Hutch nodded. "You know I
will."
The courtroom was filling back up
when they went in and took their seats. Johnson leaned over the barrier.
"Sergeant, will you be able to maintain your composure?"
"Yes," Starsky said with
that grim determination Hutch recognized.
Johnson studied him for a moment and
seemed satisfied. "I know it sounds awful, but grave dignity tends to
impress a jury more than outright emotion. I need for you to project that if
you can."
"I can."
"Sure you're okay, buddy?"
Hutch whispered before the judge came back.
Starsky patted his arm. "Yeah.
The worst part is over, believe it or not. Dr. Quo, I mean. If I made it
through that, I can handle this."
"Your honor, I call Sergeant
David Starsky to the stand."
Starsky didn't have to
"project" grave dignity. His own determination to maintain his
composure, coupled with the strain of the last few days, did that for him. He
put his hand on the Bible, took the oath, and sat down.
"Sergeant, I understand that
you and your partner have dealt with Mr. Prudholm before."
"Objection! We can't drag my
client's entire history out here!" Olin was definitely red around the
ears.
"Your client's history, Mr.
Olin, is what led to Miss Roberts' death," Greanias said. "Objection
overruled. But counselor," he added to Johnson, "only the portions of
the defendant's past that directly pertain to this case."
"Yes, your honor." Johnson
turned back to Starsky. "When was the first time you and your partner
encountered Mr. Prudholm?"
"We arrested his son,"
Starsky said. "And while Gary that was his son was in lockup, waiting
for trial, he got stabbed in a prison fight and died. Then, about four years
ago, Sergeant Hutchinson and I were involved in a shootout with a couple of
armed robbery suspects and I shot and killed one of them, a 16-year-old boy
named Lonnie Craig. Prudholm killed two of my fellow officers men I didn't
even know in retaliation..."
"Objection!" Olin rose
again.
"This does have direct pertinence
to this case, your honor," Johnson said.
"Overruled."
"Continue, Sergeant."
"Prudholm told me himself that
he killed the officers to get back at me for Lonnie's death," Starsky said
with absolute calm. Only Hutch knew what that composure was costing him.
"And he also told me that his intention was to kill my partner to punish
me for Lonnie's death. Lonnie reminded him of Gary. He tried to kill my partner
with a rigged shotgun after...he shot Terry."
"What effect did this vendetta
have on you, Officer?"
"Objection! Pejorative
language!"
"Sustained. Rephrase, Mr.
Johnson."
"Certainly, your honor. What
effect did these events have on you, Officer?"
"I considered resigning,"
Starsky said slowly. "My captain and my partner wouldn't hear of it. I
felt responsible even though I wasn't for the deaths of the other officers.
And I was treated like a pariah by many of the other officers in the
department, who blamed me for the situation."
"Let the record show,"
Johnson said, going back to his table for a file, "that Mr. Prudholm was
sent to Caballo Point State Psychiatric Hospital for treatment. After 14 months
of treatment, he was sent to San Quentin. He escaped due to a clerical error
and it is while he was free that Miss Roberts was shot." He slapped the
folder down on the table and turned back to Starsky. "Please tell the
court about the events leading up to Miss Roberts' death."
This would be the real test of
Starsky's composure. Hutch clenched his hands together in his lap and kept his
eyes on Starsky.
Starsky wet his lips and his eyes
flicked to Hutch momentarily before he answered. "My partner and I work
the inner city. There had been a string of liquor store robberies, so close
together that we were barely able to keep up with the reports, much less make
any headway with the investigation. The robberies all had the same method and
several of the witness descriptions matched up, so we were convinced it was the
same perpetrators in all the cases. Then " He stopped. Hutch could see
the effort Starsky was making. After a moment, he went on, "Then Terry was
shot in one of those robberies. And as you heard earlier, she was shot
deliberately in that robbery and Prudholm didn't even remember to take the
money until his partner reminded him. But he left a thumbprint on the cash
register and that was the evidence we needed to charge him."
Hutch shifted in his seat, knowing
the worst part of Starsky's testimony was still to come. Come on, partner.
Hang in there.
"The defendant and his partner
also attacked a friend of mine. He told us he thought the attacker was George
Prudholm and he had told him it wasn't healthy to be friends with me and my
partner."
Olin jumped to his feet.
"Objection, hearsay, move to strike."
The judge nodded. "Sustained.
Sergeant, please limit your testimony to your own experiences and do not relay
the conversations of others that were held outside your presence."
"Yes, your honor." Starsky
looked at Johnson apologetically, but the D.A. was pleased. The jury heard it,
even if the testimony was stricken. He would get the same information by
putting Huggy Bear on the stand later in the trial.
Starsky paused to take a sip of
water from a cup the D.A. had filled and placed there just before he took the
stand. He shot Johnson a grateful look. Hutch watched his hand and noticed it
shook a little when he picked up the glass.
Johnson continued, "Sergeant,
did you help Terry make the decision to leave the hospital?"
Hutch winced at that question. He
knew his partner was sensitive about that, but Starsky continued calmly.
"No, Terry wanted to make that decision on her own, I just supported her
in it."
"After she left the hospital,
was Terry able to live her life fairly normally?"
"Yes, up until the last day.
She wasn't able to do anything strenuous, but she chose to work and live her
life like nothing was wrong. That's what she wanted."
"What did the defendant do
after she died?"
Olin was on his feet again,
"Objection, relevance!"
Johnson replied, "This
testimony corroborates the witness' contention that the defendant's actions
during this time were all part of a personal vendetta against him, including
the shooting of his fianceι."
The judge considered for a moment.
Hutch noticed Starsky was looking a little pale, but he seemed to be all right.
"I'll allow it, you may answer
the question, Sergeant."
"The defendant took two women
hostage in a warehouse and demanded I come or he would kill them."
"Were you worried about your
own safety?"
"Yes, I thought he planned to
blow my head off when I got there. I just wanted to get the hostages out of
there so no one else would be hurt because of me."
"Did you successfully resolve
the situation?"
Starsky shifted in his seat.
"Yes, my partner and I got the hostages out of there and re-arrested
Prudholm."
"Thank you, Sergeant Starsky. I
know this is not easy for you. The prosecution is done with this witness at
this time but we reserve the right to recall him for rebuttal if
necessary."
"So noted. Mr. Olin, your
witness."
Hutch watched tensely as Johnson sat
back down and whispered something to his colleague from the D.A.'s office. She
scribbled some notes on a legal pad. Olin let Starsky squirm on the stand for
extra moments while he slowly stood and made his way in front of the witness
box. Starsky took another sip of water while he waited. This was the part Hutch
dreaded the most and he could see his partner struggle to maintain control.
When Starsky looked up at him briefly, Hutch could tell he was somewhere else.
To him, Starsky looked like he had removed himself from the past concentrating
only on this moment in time.
The defense attorney attempted to
appear concerned for Starsky. "Are you all right to continue,
Sergeant?"
"I'm fine."
"We could ask for a
recess?"
Hutch could see Starsky was getting
angry. He tensed; hoping it would be the cold, cop anger that Starsky was
capable of when necessary. Starsky could be intimidating in that mode. If he
could hold onto that, he would be fine.
"I said I'm fine,
counselor." Hutch nodded at him slightly. Hold onto that, Gordo.
"Sergeant Starsky, did you try
to talk your fianceι out of leaving the hospital?"
"No. She had a right to make up
her own mind."
"Do you think maybe if you had
talked her out of it, she would have lived longer?"
"The outcome would have been
the same. She'd still be dead." Hutch hoped his buddy wouldn't have to say
that too many more times.
Olin swallowed and pulled on the
knot of his tie. "Very well. Sergeant, are you aware that your police
record shows you have killed 17 people during your service to the people of Bay
City?"
"Objection!" Johnson
shouted. "What possible relevance could that have here?"
Hutch watched the emotions play out
on Starsky's face as only he would notice them, shock, hurt, sadness,
disbelief, and finally anger. His eyes flashed with it. He sat on the stand and
watched the interchange between the lawyers and the judge. Sitting on the stand
with everyone watching while three people talked about him as if he were not
present never sat well with Starsky. He was used to it from the many court
appearances he had made throughout his career.
"Your honor, I'd like to
establish this police officer's record of aggressive behavior as a mitigating
factor to my client's obsession with him."
"That's ludicrous, your honor.
This man is a police officer. No matter how many criminals he has killed, that
doesn't excuse the defendant from the cold-blooded murder of an innocent young
woman."
"I'll allow it."
"Sidebar, your honor."
"Approach the bench."
The look Starsky gave Hutch told him
how much he wanted this to be over so he could stop being the center of
attention. His grief and pain over Terry was palpable, but he was keeping
everything in check. Hutch smiled at him a little and gave him a look back that
said, "Hang in there. I'm proud of you, buddy." He did his best to
tune out the bickering attorneys standing practically in front of him.
"Your honor," Johnson
started, "Mr. Olin is trying to impugn this witness' character. The number
of people he has killed in the line of duty has nothing to do with this
case."
"I disagree, your honor. I have
witnesses to call who will confirm that this officer's aggressive tactics drove
my client to madness. I am just trying to establish his behavior as a
pattern."
The judge looked from one attorney
to the other, then over at Starsky. He was looking out at his partner and
wouldn't make eye contact with the judge.
"Step back, gentlemen."
"I'm going to allow it, but be
careful, Mr. Olin. This witness is a decorated officer with long and
outstanding service to the people of this community. You are skating on thin
ice and you'd better show some relevance to this line of questioning or I'll
hold you in contempt."
"Yes, your honor. Do you need
me to restate the question, officer?"
"No, I heard you. Yes, I did
know."
"Does that number seem
unusually high to you?"
"My partner and I work the
inner city, counselor. I've been a cop for a long time. I would like it to be
lower, but it is what it is. No, the number doesn't seem high."
Olin walked back to the defense
table and retrieved a document.
"Your honor, I would like to
enter this list as Defense Exhibit A and I would like it read into the record.
This is a list of the names of the people this witness has killed."
"Objection!" Johnson was
angry now. Starsky's jaw clenched tighter and he sat back in the chair, trying
to maintain his composure while the attorneys fought over the list.
"Objection sustained. Mr. Olin,
you are out of line. This line of questioning is over and the jury will
disregard the testimony in this matter."
Hutch was seething. He clenched and
unclenched his fists and looked at his partner, making sure he was all right.
Starsky looked about as angry as he had ever seen him and he was completely
still. This was not a normal state of being for Starsky and Hutch was concerned
about what this entire ordeal was doing to his friend.
"But your honor . . ."
Olin started.
The judge looked at him coolly and
said, "Mr. Olin, one more word and you are in contempt. Move on now."
Olin looked disappointed as he returned
the list to his brief case. Hutch watched him cautiously; certain he was not
done tormenting Starsky.
"Sergeant, didn't you shoot my
client in the old city zoo several years ago?"
"Yes, he was trying to blow my
head off with a shotgun."
"Is it true that after you had
him in your custody you tried to kill him?"
Starsky's eyes were dark with anger.
His voice was tightly controlled, "No. If I had tried to kill him, he'd be
dead."
"Isn't it true that you had
your gun pointed at Mr. Prudholm's head and your partner prevented you from
pulling the trigger?"
"I didn't try to kill him, but
I did point my gun at him." Starsky glared at the defense attorney,
obviously making him squirm. Then he looked over at Prudholm who was smiling
that evil smile. Olin let Starsky's last remark hang in the air for a few
moments, pretending he was considering the next question.
"Nothing further, your
honor."
Starsky stood and stepped out of the
witness box, staring Prudholm down as he passed back into the witness area of the
courtroom.
"The State calls Sergeant
Kenneth Hutchinson."
The two detectives touched arms
briefly as they passed, each one giving the other a reassuring look of
solidarity. As Hutch turned to be sworn in, he glanced toward Prudholm.
Incredibly, the look of hatred the man was wearing seemed more intense toward
Hutch than it had toward his partner.
"Sergeant Hutchinson, you and
Sergeant Starsky have been partners for some time, isn't that correct?"
"Yes, many years." Hutch
looked away from Prudholm and concentrated on Mark Johnson.
"Were you partners when
Sergeant Starsky arrested Gary Prudholm?"
"Yes, that was our first
undercover assignment. We were under in a high school trying to bust drug
dealers."
"Was Gary Prudholm dealing
drugs?"
"Yes, he was. My partner made
the collar."
"Did either you or Sergeant
Starsky harm Gary Prudholm?"
"No, it was a clean bust, easy.
He didn't even resist arrest."
"Did Gary Prudholm have a
previous record?"
"He had been arrested a number
of times as a juvenile, but this was his first offense as an adult."
"Sergeant Starsky testified
that Gary Prudholm was killed in jail within days of his arrest. Is that
accurate?"
"Yes, I think it was less than
two days."
"You and your partner had
nothing to do with his death?"
Olin was on his feet.
"Objection, your honor, relevance to this case?"
"I'm trying to establish that
neither of these officers had any malice for Gary Prudholm, nor were they
directly involved in his death."
"Overruled."
"Sergeant Hutchinson, did you or
your partner have anything to do with his death?"
"No."
Johnson walked toward the jury, his
back to Hutch for a moment, then he asked, "Did you know Terry
Roberts?"
"Yes, she was a friend."
"By nature of her relationship
with your partner?"
"Yes, at first, but then in her
own right. Terry was a wonderful person and a good friend." Hutch looked
at Starsky. He still had the fire of anger in his eyes, but they were bright
and Hutch knew he would not be able to maintain his composure through this line
of questioning if he didn't break eye contact.
"Your partner has described the
events leading up to Terry's death. How did this situation affect the two of
them?"
Hutch blinked back the tears that
were starting to form in his eyes, then he drank some water too, stalling long
enough to get a grip on his emotions. He kept telling himself that if Starsky
could sit there and maintain control, he could too. He took a deep breath
before answering.
"Terry was brave. She was
frightened, but she kept living every day like she had before the shooting. My
partner was devastated. We both were." He swallowed and took another
breath before adding, "I loved her too."
Hutch knew he didn't dare look at
Starsky, but he did look over at Prudholm. The hatred, anger, and pure evil on
the man's face angered Hutch. The man had taken Starsky's future as a husband
and probably a father away from him. Who knew if Starsky would ever meet
another woman who could replace Terry? Hutch's anger helped him to focus and he
put on his best, steely Nordic face.
"In your opinion, Sergeant,
does your partner blame himself for the deaths of those two policemen and for
Terry's death?"
"Objection!" Olin shouted.
"This man can't speak for his partner in that way!"
The judge looked to Johnson for some
plausible justification to allow the question.
"Your honor, this man and
Sergeant Starsky have been partners for years. They know each other well and
they spend a lot of time together. I think it is fair to state the Sergeant
Hutchinson is an expert on the subject of his partner. I'd like the jury to
hear the answer."
The judge thought about it, looking
first at Hutch, then at Starsky. He could see the blond was purposely avoiding
eye contact with his partner. He and Starsky had maintained that contact
throughout much of Starsky's testimony and the judge could see the pain and
grief on both men's faces. "I agree, Mr. Johnson, I'll allow it."
Hutch looked Prudholm in the eye
when he answered. "Yes, I do. I think my partner carries that pain every
day of his life."
"Thank you, Sergeant
Hutchinson. I have no further questions at this time, but the State reserves
the right to recall you as a rebuttal witness if necessary."
Johnson returned to the prosecution
table, giving Starsky a reassuring glance before he sat down again. He was
satisfied with Hutch's testimony.
Olin sat at the table for a moment,
studying Hutch, before he rose and walked toward the witness box.
"Sergeant," he said very conversationally, "you remarked a
moment ago that you loved Miss Roberts, too. Are we to understand that was a
romantic love? Were you involved with her sexually?"
Hutch stared at him, unable to find
his voice for a moment. "Of-of course not!" he said at last.
"She was engaged to my b-best friend!"
"I see," Olin said in a
tone implying he didn't believe it for a moment. "So this 'love' you had
for Miss Roberts was purely platonic? You loved her as a friend?"
Now Hutch was angry. "Yes,
counselor, I believe I said that earlier."
"Were you at all jealous of her
relationship with your partner?"
"Objection!" Johnson shot
out of his chair. "Your honor, I fail to see the point of this line of
questioning!"
"I agree. Sustained. Counselor,
please confine yourself to the case."
"Your honor," Olin said,
spreading his hands, "I am trying to establish this witness'
character."
"This witness is not on trial
here, counselor. Confine yourself to the case."
"Of course," Olin said.
"Sergeant, how often do you draw your gun in the line of duty?"
Hutch wet his lips and took another
sip of water. "A couple of times a week, I guess."
"And how often do you fire
it?"
"Only when absolutely
necessary."
"How often have you fired it in
the last month?" Olin persisted.
Hutch glanced at Starsky. His
partner was glaring at Olin's back as if he wanted to strangle him with his
bare hands and Hutch tried to convey to him to stop it. Starsky's eyes drifted
to Hutch and Hutch could see him consciously smooth his face. He looked back to
Olin. "Twice," he said.
"Did you shoot a person?"
"No," Hutch said.
"One shot was fired into the air as a warning. The second missed,
deliberately."
"Sergeant, isn't it true that
you and your partner are known for rather unorthodox methods?"
"We get results," Hutch
said.
"I see," Olin said.
"So you consistently ignore rules and procedure, but that's all right as
long as you get results?"
"Objection!" Johnson was
livid. "Your honor, this has no bearing on this case!"
"If my client believed that
these two officers were reckless in their use of deadly force, your
honor," Olin said, "it would help explain why he behaved as he
did."
The judge considered that.
"I'll allow it, with reservations, counselor."
"We do not 'ignore' procedure,
counselor," Hutch said with icy calm.
Olin returned to his table and
picked up a file. "I would like to place into evidence," he said,
"these official records of Sergeants Starsky and Hutchinson. This,"
he added, "is a warrant issued for the arrest of Sergeant Hutchinson in
the murder of his former wife, Vanessa Hutchinson, in 1978."
"I was exonerated," Hutch
said in a level voice, though his heart was thudding in his chest.
"And these," Olin went on
as though Hutch had not spoken, "are federal warrants issued for both
Sergeant Starsky and Sergeant Hutchinson in 1977 for the murder of federally
protected witness Joe Durniak."
"Objection!" Johnson was
on his feet again. "Both those cases were extensively covered in the
newspapers, your honor, and in both cases these two officers were framed by the
real perpetrators."
"Counselor?" Greanias said
to Olin. "Can you justify bringing this up?"
"I can, your honor. My point is
that these two officers would not have been suspected if they had not proven
themselves to be loose cannons."
"Loose cannons!" Hutch
spluttered, but a look from Johnson made him choke back the rest.
Greanias considered and finally
shook his head. "I concur with the prosecution, Mr. Olin. It has nothing
to do with the case at hand."
Olin's face looked disappointed, but
Hutch was close enough to see his eyes, and he saw a self-satisfied glitter
there. Olin had made his point to the jury and was quite willing to abandon
that line of questioning.
"Sergeant," Olin went on
as if there had been no interruption, "have you ever lost a loved one to a
criminal's actions?"
Hutch's heartbeat sped up another
notch and he looked down. And did not answer immediately.
"Sergeant?" Olin repeated
pleasantly. "Please answer the question."
"Yes," Hutch said very
softly.
"I'm sorry, I couldn't hear
you. Please raise your voice."
"Yes!" Hutch said, and
felt his eyes sting again. He took a deep breath and tried to control his face.
"And who was that?"
"My girlfriend."
"Yes, her name was Gillian
Ingram, wasn't it? A prostitute and porn movie actress, murdered by her
employer," Olin said. "How did her death affect you, Sergeant?"
"Objection! Relevance!"
Johnson demanded.
"The relevance is the witness'
sympathy with Sergeant Starsky's situation and his attitude toward my client as
a result," Olin said.
"The defense is badgering the
witness!" Johnson insisted.
"Approach the bench,"
Greanias said.
Both attorneys came to the bench and
Greanias leaned forward. "We are trying Mr. Prudholm for murder," he
said. "We are not trying either one of these officers. Their attitudes do
not change the fact that a young woman is dead and would not be dead if someone
had not fired a bullet into her brain. Our purpose here is to establish whether
Mr. Prudholm did, in fact, fire that bullet into her brain and whether he is to
be held responsible for that act. Do I make myself clear, Mr. Olin?"
"Yes, your honor."
"Can you convince me that
Sergeant Hutchinson's loss is material to this trial?"
"Yes, your honor," Olin
said. "A pattern of recklessness and unorthodoxy in the course of their
work contributed to the breakdown of my client's mental health to the point
that he is not responsible for his actions in the death of Miss Roberts."
Greanias nodded. "All right.
But keep it relevant, understand?"
"Yes, your honor." Olin
gave Johnson a sidelong look and turned back to Hutch. "Sergeant, please
describe the scene the day Lonnie Craig died."
Hutch forced himself to stay calm.
He knew quite well why Olin had left the question of Gillian where he had. The
jury would remember that Hutch's girlfriend had been a prostitute, but would
not know that he hadn't been aware of that fact. It made him look dirty.
There was nothing he could do about
it now. "My partner and I answered a call to assist at a robbery. When we
arrived, uniformed officers were already on the scene. Shots were fired and the
two suspects ran. My partner was ahead of me, and pursued them into the alley.
One suspect got away, and as my partner came around the corner, he fired a
warning shot and ordered the second suspect, Lonnie Craig, to stop. Lonnie
turned and started to bring his gun down into firing position and my partner,
knowing there were innocent bystanders behind him, shot him."
"And Lonnie died?"
Hutch nodded. "Yes."
"How old was Lonnie Craig,
Sergeant?"
"16."
"Did you partner realize this
at the time?"
"No, he did not!"
"What was your partner's
reaction to the knowledge that he had killed a 16-year-old boy?"
Hutch gave Starsky an apologetic
look. "He was understandably upset. No police officer enjoys using deadly
force, counselor. But in this case, my partner had no choice. Lonnie was going
to shoot. He might have killed my partner or one of the people behind him.
Starsky had no choice but to shoot."
"Did he have to shoot to
kill?" Olin inquired.
"We are trained to shoot to
kill if our lives or the lives of innocent people are in danger, Mr. Olin.
Starsky believed his life and the lives of those innocent people were in
danger. He reacted according to his training. He was exonerated for it."
"Yes, he was," Olin said,
turning as if to rest his hand on the witness box, but the movement made him
face the jury. "It seems you and your partner often find yourselves in the
position of having to be 'exonerated' for your actions, Sergeant."
"Objection!" Johnson all
but shouted.
"Nothing further, your honor."
Olin went back to his seat.
Greanias glared after him.
"This court will recess until 9 a.m. tomorrow morning."
The detectives pushed past the
throng of reporters and cameras on their way out to the car, putting their
hands up in front of their faces and muttering a string of "no
comment" statements. After the emotional wringer they had just been
through, neither one of them wanted to face the blaring lights or obnoxious
questions.
Starsky pulled out of the courthouse
parking lot with a squeal of rubber without even being sure where he was going.
He drove in silence for several miles, his hands clutching the steering wheel,
making his knuckles white. Hutch looked over at him every few minutes,
concerned about the rage his partner was holding. When Starsky turned the
Torino onto the streets headed for the beach, he knew where they were going and
he held his silence.
The car stopped along the boardwalk.
Starsky took off his tie with shaking hands, and then his jacket, throwing them
in the back seat. Then, without a word to Hutch he shut the door and took off
running down the boardwalk. Hutch wasn't ready for that. Starsky had worn his
Adidas to court, but Hutch was in dress shoes. Even though his legs were
longer, when Starsky had a head of steam up, Hutch didn't stand a chance of
being able to catch him until he wound down on his own. Instead, he sat in the
car and composed himself, allowing the tears he had kept in check at the trial
to flow. Starsky had been gone about ten minutes when the radio signaled.
"Zebra 3 from Control, come in
please."
Hutch took a deep breath before
answering. "This is Zebra 3, go ahead."
"Patch through from Captain
Dobey."
He waited a few seconds, then heard
the concerned voice come through the speaker. "Hutch, how's he
doing?"
"He's hurting, Cap." That
was an understatement.
"You keep an eye on him and
call me if you need anything."
"Roger that, Cap." Hutch
hung up the mike. He would wait a few more minutes before starting out in the
direction Starsky had taken. An hour later he spotted his partner sitting on a
swing in the sand, watching the setting sun.
Hutch walked out onto the sand and
took a seat in the swing next to Starsky's. He could see his friend had been
crying and now he was shivering from the cool late afternoon breeze.
Hutch sat quietly for a few minutes,
then said, "I'm sorry, partner."
Starsky didn't respond and they both
stared out at the beautiful colors in the sky. After a few minutes, Starsky
said, "You know, Hutch, I was just sittin' here thinking about all the
sunsets Terry won't ever see and how that scum Prudholm is still walking around
alive."
"I know. We're gonna get him
though, Gordo. All that crap the lawyer pulled today doesn't mean a thing.
Won't do him any good, he's goin' down this time."
Starsky sighed deeply. "You
ever think about it, Hutch? How many people we've killed?"
Hutch knew that was going to weigh
heavily on his friend's conscience. "Buddy, I think if we spend too much
time thinking about that kind of thing it might not be possible to stay on the
job. We do what we have to do. You know that."
The dark-haired man was pensive.
After a few more minutes he said, "You were right, Hutch."
"Right about what, buddy?"
Starsky swallowed hard, blinking
back more tears. "I do still blame myself. I do, 'cause it's my
fault."
"No it isn't, Starsk."
This wasn't the first time they had gone over this subject. Hutch knew the best
he could ever hope for was that Starsky might put it out of his mind for a
while. He knew his best friend would never really forgive himself for Terry's
death, or the deaths of those two policemen.
"Hutch?" Starsky's voice
sounded far away.
"Yeah?"
"Why do defense lawyers do it?
Can that guy really think it's good what he's doin'? Tryin' to make us look bad
and save that creep from the gas chamber?"
Hutch had no answer for that.
Starsky wasn't finished. "I'm sorry, Hutch. Sorry you had to go through
that. The stuff he asked you today, Gillian, and about your relationship with
Terry. That was just wrong. I'm sorry you had to be a witness."
"I'll get over it,
Starsk."
"You know the judge didn't
dismiss you. You've got to be back up there again first thing tomorrow."
Hutch hadn't thought of that.
"Well, at least that jerk Olin is done with me. Any other questions will
be rebuttal ones from our guy. Piece of cake."
They sat that way until the sun
slowly slid beneath the waves.
"You ready to go back,
partner?" Hutch asked.
Starsky nodded. "Yep, I'm
freezin' now. Let's go over to Huggy's and catch him up on the trial. Maybe
he's got some chili going tonight."
The walk back to the car was long
and punctuated by strained silence. They were both too tired to talk about it
anymore and they were preparing themselves for Huggy's. He would want all the
details.
~*~*~*~
The two men were back in the
courtroom the following morning. Both of them were grateful that Hutch's part
would soon be over and they could sit back and watch the rest of the trial
having surpassed the hurdle of their individual testimonies. The D.A. recalled
Hutch to the stand for redirect.
"I remind you, Sergeant
Hutchinson, you are still under oath."
Hutch nodded that he understood.
"Sergeant, you were asked about
Gillian Ingram yesterday. Is it true that she was a prostitute?"
"Yes." Hutch already
disliked the direction this was taking.
"Did you know what she did for
a living when you were dating her?"
A little flash of relief crept into
Hutch's eyes. Johnson was giving him a chance to recover from this situation in
the eyes of the jury.
"No. She told me she was a
writer."
"When did you find out about
it?"
"After she was dead."
"Tell me about how you found
out what she did for a living."
"Objection! What difference
does that make, your honor?" Olin asked.
"You opened this line of
questioning, Mr. Olin, and I'm allowing it. Please answer the question,
Sergeant."
"Yes, sir. My partner told me.
He had just found out that day and was giving Gillian a chance to tell me
herself. She was killed before she could tell me."
"Thank you, Sergeant."
He paced back to the table and
withdrew a stack of papers from his briefcase.
"Did you know that the
defendant has been writing letters to you threatening your life since his
transfer back to San Quentin?"
Olin was on his feet instantly.
"I object! Move to suppress those letters."
Hutch looked stunned. He found
Starsky's eyes and received the message that his partner was also unaware of
any threatening letters.
Suddenly, Starsky's danger sense was
on full alert. The idea that crazy George Prudholm still harbored fantasies of
hurting Hutch unnerved him.
Greanias looked at both attorneys
and called them up to the bench. "Gentlemen?"
Olin looked furious. "Your
honor, these letters were not disclosed to me."
Johnson responded that he had just
been made aware of them the previous evening when they were delivered from the
prison. He asked the judge to admit them into evidence and refuse the defense
attorney's motion to suppress.
"Step back, gentlemen."
Hutch sat on the stand, quietly
waiting for what he should do next. The judge turned to address the jury.
"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I'm going to ask you to step outside
for a few moments while I hear the Motion to Suppress. Please do not discuss
the case at this time."
The jury having received its
instructions, the bailiff approached them to escort the group into a waiting
room. The bailiff was a heavyset, sixty-year-old man who had been in court
service for many years. He didn't react fast enough to what happened next.
The bailiff was standing next to the
defense table with his back to Prudholm. Before anyone knew what was happening,
Prudholm jumped to his feet and grabbed the bailiff's gun right out of its
holster. Starsky saw it happening and he yelled for Hutch to get down, but it
was too late. Hutch was just starting to move when Prudholm swung the gun up,
aimed, and fired at the unprepared detective before the other guard
accompanying Prudholm could tackle him and wrestle the gun out of his grasp.
Starsky watched in horror as Hutch
grabbed the side of his head and crumpled to the floor of the witness box. He
vaulted over the barrier in front of the witness gallery, calling his partner's
name and hearing Prudholm's rantings in the background. As he was manhandled
out of the courtroom, Prudholm was hurling obscenities at Starsky and yelling
about how he'd finally gotten Hutch.
Hutch lay unconscious, blood running
through the fingers he held up to his temple. Starsky was terrified.
"Hutch? Oh, God. Hutch?" He knelt beside Hutch; afraid
of what he would see when he moved his partner's hand away from the wound. His
heart was racing, remembering how Terry had looked lying on the stretcher in
the liquor store with a bullet hole in her forehead. He heard someone yell for
an ambulance over the pandemonium in the courtroom.
When he moved Hutch's hand, he was
relieved to see the bullet had not gone into his head, but had clipped him in
the temple and was now lodged in the wall behind the witness box. Starsky was
still scared. The wound was bleeding profusely and Hutch was unconscious, but
he didn't have a bullet in his brain. This wasn't going to be like Terry.
Starsky pulled Hutch's head onto his
lap and ran his fingers through his blood-matted hair. "I'm here, Hutch.
Paramedics will be here soon. Don't go away now, you're gonna be fine." He
sat like that with Hutch, not caring that his clothes were being soaked with
his partner's blood, until the paramedics came and made him let them take Hutch
away.
That bastard! That slime! Starsky paced in the emergency
waiting area, fuming, terrified, his heart pounding and his hands sweaty and
his light tan dress pants stiffening with Hutch's blood. It had been over two
hours and there was still no word about Hutch.
Huggy sat on a bench a few feet
away, nursing a cold cup of coffee and watching the swinging doors, but Starsky
couldn't sit still. Dobey was still at the jail, pressing further charges
against Prudholm, but what good would that do? If he copped insanity for Terry
again, he'd get off for hurting Hutch, too....
"David?"
Starsky froze and turned. It was Dr.
Quo and he remembered that tone of voice all too well. His heart stopped
thudding. It might have stopped altogether.
"I've seen your partner,"
she said, coming closer.
"How is he?"
She reached out and took his hand.
"He's going to be fine."
"Thank God," Huggy said
fervently, but Starsky's eyes overflowed for a moment before he could control
the tears and he couldn't speak.
"We're keeping him
overnight," Dr. Quo went on. "He lost a lot of blood and we're giving
him a transfusion. We also want to make sure there are no after-effects."
"After-effects?"
"A concussion, or convulsions
from the trauma to his brain," she said gently.
"What do you mean?"
Hearing Starsky's panicked tone of
voice, Dr. Quo squeezed his hand. "Nothing lasting, David. But the shock,
the impact as the bullet struck, could have caused the same kind of injury as
if he'd hit his head. It's nothing to worry about, I promise. You can pick him
up in the morning, and I'll want him to be quiet for a couple of days."
"I wanna see him."
"Of course."
Starsky entered the room slowly,
Huggy behind him. Hutch's room was darkened, with only a small light over the
bed. He had a white bandage wound around his head, and his eyes were closed. An
IV with a bag of blood on it stood next to the bed, with a tube running down to
his left arm. Starsky crept over to the bed, while Huggy hung back, and reached
down to touch Hutch's hand.
Hutch opened his eyes. He was
groggy, but he recognized his partner.
"How ya doin', Hutch?"
"I've got one hell of a
headache," Hutch said, and tried to smile. The lost, haunted look on
Starsky's face almost broke his heart. "Other than that, I'm fine."
Starsky smiled back. It was a little forced, but he hoped in the dimness Hutch
wouldn't be able to tell. "You gotta spend the night here. Dr. Quo likes
your face."
Hutch gave a little snort of
laughter. "The lady has taste."
"I'll be back for ya in the
morning and then you get to be lazy for a couple of days," Starsky said.
"Your place or mine?"
"Mine," Hutch said. He
noticed Huggy standing near the door. "And maybe Hug'd be willing to bring
me one of Angie's vegetarian omelettes."
Starsky made a face, but Huggy
grinned. "You bet, Blondie. It'll be waitin' when you get there
tomorrow."
~*~*~*~
The next morning, the whole side of
Hutch's face was bruised and his left eye was black, but his headache had
eased, and Dr. Quo prescribed some painkillers to keep it away. Starsky fussed
over him, held onto his arm as he loaded him into the car, insisted on helping
him walk up the stairs to Venice Place, and bedded him down on the couch with
an afghan and a pillow for both his head and his feet. Huggy had left the
omelette, as promised, and Starsky warmed it up and brought it to him with a
cup of coffee, then sat down on the coffee table to watch him eat it.
Hutch stood it as long as he could,
but finally had to say, "Starsk, buddy, I appreciate the nursemaid
routine, but I'm okay. Really."
Starsky didn't speak right away, but
he dropped his eyes and Hutch saw the movement as he drew and let out a very
deep breath.
"Starsk?"
"I was so scared," Starsky
said in a low voice, as if he was picking up an earlier conversation that had
been interrupted. "When I saw you layin' there, with blood all over ya, in
your hair and on your face, I "
"Hey," Hutch sat up and
put the plate aside. "I understand, but look. I'm fine."
"It's my fault. Again,"
Starsky said.
"No, it's not!" Hutch
instantly regretted raising his voice. It made his head throb. But he didn't let
on. "Starsky, that's just nuts. It's not your fault. Prudholm has wanted
to kill us both for years. He's never succeeded yet. And it is not," he
reached out and laid a hand on his partner's, "your fault!"
"Why's he keep doing this,
Hutch?" Starsky asked plaintively. "I don't get it."
"He's evil, I keep telling
you." Hutch didn't have the strength to sit up any longer. He lay back
down and squashed the moan that almost escaped.
But Starsky knew. He always knew.
"Ah, buddy, I'm sorry. You finish your omelette and try to get some sleep,
huh? I know you don't sleep good in hospitals."
"I am kind of tired,"
Hutch admitted.
Hutch was still sleeping a couple of
hours later when the phone rang. Starsky pounced on the bedroom extension
before it could wake Hutch. It was Johnson.
"How is he?"
"Sleeping. He'll be okay."
"Will he be able to be in court
Monday?"
"Does he have to be?"
Starsky leaned out so he could check on Hutch. Still sleeping.
"I'd like for both of you to be
there."
"Still usin' us for
effect?" Starsky asked, unable to keep the note of bitterness out of his
voice.
"Sergeant," Johnson gave a
sigh and gentled his voice. "I know how you feel. Or at least, I'm trying
to understand. But you need to understand, too, that if we want to put this guy
away, we have to put on a good show for the jury. We have to convince them he's
not crazy. And frankly, Sergeant, the sight of your partner, wounded by this
man but still brave enough to sit in the same courtroom with him, will go a
long way toward engendering sympathy for you and him and antagonism toward
Prudholm."
"My partner and I are not chess
pieces!" Starsky hissed, trying to keep his voice down. "And that
worthless bastard Prudholm damn near killed him in a courtroom full of people
yesterday! What kind of a circus are you running here, Johnson?"
"That was completely
unforeseen," Johnson said.
"Why the hell wasn't he
shackled?" Starsky demanded.
"I don't know," Johnson
said. "You can rest assured he will be for the rest of the trial."
"I should hope so!"
~*~*~*~
There was a great deal of murmuring
among the spectators when Starsky and Hutch entered the courtroom on Monday
morning. Hutch was pale, and the angry bruise around his left eye was worse
than ever, but some of the swelling had gone down. Starsky's arm was around his
partner and he helped him to his seat behind the prosecution's table before he
seated himself.
When Prudholm was brought in, he was
shackled hand and foot, and the deputy who was guarding him stood right behind him,
with one hand on his gun. Starsky couldn't help giving Prudholm a look of
hatred, but he managed to smooth his face when Hutch put a hand on his arm and
whispered, "Choke it down, partner."
The first thing the defense did when
court reconvened was file a motion for a mistrial. Instantly, Starsky was
enraged. Hutch looked at him with concern, knowing how much this trial had
already cost them both. Going through it again might be too much for his
partner.
Olin had prepared his statement.
"Your honor, in light of what happened here on Friday," he said as he
turned to indicate the wounded blond detective sitting in the witness gallery,
"the defense believes that the jury will no longer be able to be impartial
in this case."
Johnson was ready for him. "Your
honor, the people strenuously object. The state and the witnesses in this
matter have been through enough. I request that this motion be denied."
The judge sat and considered the
motion. He decided to poll the jury. "Ladies and gentleman of the jury, I
will ask each one of you to stand and state for the record if you believe you
can remain impartial in the matter before you. Mr. Foreman, please begin."
The court sat breathless, watching
as the jurors stood and declared their ability to be impartial one after the
other. All twelve jurors and the three alternates responded that they could be
impartial.
The judge faced the attorneys.
"I am not about to reward this man for his behavior of the other day by
granting him a mistrial. The jurors have stated under oath that they can still
judge this case on its merits, regardless of the shooting here on Friday. The
motion is denied. I have also considered the matter of the threatening letters
mentioned just before the defendant's attack on Sergeant Hutchinson. Does the
defense still move to have them suppressed?"
"Yes, your honor."
"Please step into my chambers
and I will hear your motion." The judge did not want to take the time to
file the jury out again and then return them to the courtroom.
While they were out of the room,
Starsky noticed all eyes seemed to be on him and Hutch. He felt uncomfortable
and he could see how Hutch felt about it. "You doin' okay?"
"I'm all right, Starsk."
Hutch's head was pounding and he wished he could have taken one of the pain
pills Dr. Quo had prescribed. Technically, he had not been excused from the
stand so he decided not to take anything in case he was called back up there.
Starsky patted his pocket and Hutch heard something rattle. "You hang in
there, partner. Soon as you're excused and we get to take a recess, I've got
your pain pills right here." Hutch smiled at him and nodded his thanks.
His partner didn't miss much.
Within a few minutes, the judge and
the attorneys returned to the court. Olin looked disappointed and the two detectives
smiled at each other.
"The motion to suppress the
threatening letters is denied."
The judge looked at Hutch.
"Sergeant Hutchinson, you are still on the stand. Are you able to
testify?"
"Yes, your honor."
Starsky watched him stand and walk
slowly back to the witness stand. Hutch looked terrible and it gave Starsky no
pleasure to know that Johnson was getting exactly what he wanted Hutch on the
stand, wounded and on display.
Johnson played it up as much as he
could. "Sergeant Hutchinson, you are still under oath. Are you sure you
feel up to this?"
Starsky rolled his eyes. Twelve
pairs of eyes in the jury box were trained on Hutch's face. Starsky could see
them looking at his bruised partner and knew it would affect them.
"Yes, go ahead." Hutch sounded
tired and his voice was quiet.
"Were you aware that the
defendant had been writing letters threatening your life?"
"No."
"These letters were addressed
to Sergeant Starsky and they were held by the prison. They never notified
you?"
Olin stood. "Objection, your
honor, asked and answered. The witness did not know about them."
"Sustained."
"I will enter these letters
into evidence as People's Exhibit A. I have nothing further for this witness.
Sergeant Hutchinson, you may step down."
Hutch made his way back to his seat
next to Starsky, who wished that his obvious pain and slow pace were just an
act for the jury. He glared at Prudholm, who was looking satisfied that he had
hurt Hutch, even if he didn't kill him.
Johnson's next witness was Huggy.
"Please tell the court about
the incident where you were assaulted, Mr. Brown."
"I was with a female
acquaintance," Huggy said, "when three men broke in and dragged me
out of bed and beat me up. They told me I should choose my friends more
carefully."
"Did you recognize any of the
men?"
Huggy nodded. "Yeah. I wasn't
supposed to. They were wearing masks. But I knew their voices. One of them was
George Prudholm. The second one was Woody the Magic Man. I didn't know the
third one."
"You're sure it was George
Prudholm?"
"Yeah. I'm sure."
"Did they say anything
else?"
"Prudholm said if I didn't quit
hanging around with Starsky and Hutch, next time they'd kill me, just like
they'd killed Terry."
"Was Terry alive or dead at
this point?"
"She was still alive," Huggy
said. "But I guess they didn't know that. Prudholm's exact words were,
'I'll come back and kill you like I killed Starsky's lady.'"
Starsky flinched at that.
"Your witness, Mr. Olin."
"How can you be so sure it was
my client who assaulted you, Mr. Brown?"
"I knew his voice. I also
recognized that tattoo on his arm."
Olin blanched a bit. The tattoo was
old and faded and most people didn't notice it. "You were acquainted with
my client, then?"
"Everybody on the streets knows
Crazy George Prudholm," Huggy said coolly.
"Your honor! Move to
strike!"
"You asked the question, Mr.
Olin," Greanias said. "Overruled."
"Nothing further," Olin
said sullenly.
Johnson called the psychiatrist from
Caballo Point who had been treating Prudholm, and the doctor testified that
Prudholm had often bragged to other patients about "getting over on the
system" by convincing the evaluator he was crazy. Though he had convinced
the psychiatrist who had been at Caballo Point when he was committed, when this
doctor, Evan Duncan, had joined the staff, he had realized the man could be
faking it and had reported that to the district attorney, who had called in an
expert to do a new evaluation. That new evaluation had resulted in Prudholm's
being found competent to stand trial.
Olin waived his cross-examination.
"Your next witness, Mr.
Johnson?"
"The state calls Dr. Lloyd
Hill."
Hill had written several books on
criminal psychology. After Johnson had questioned him as to his credentials and
it had been established that he was a specialist in the field, Hill testified
that Prudholm was obsessive and antisocial, but he was not legally
"insane."
"This man is calculating,"
Hill said. "He is fully aware of the implications of his actions and
chooses to carry them out anyway."
"Did you administer any
psychological tests, Doctor?" Johnson asked.
"I did. I administered a
battery of widely accepted psychological tests, two weeks ago."
"Is it your professional
opinion that Mr. Prudholm is competent to understand these proceedings and
assist in his own defense?"
"It is."
"And is it your professional
opinion that the defendant was not suffering from a mental illness at the time
of Miss Roberts' shooting?"
"That is correct. Mr. Prudholm
was and is fully cognizant of the nature, extent, and wrongfulness of the crime
at the time he committed it. His judgment is poor, and he externalized the
blame for his son's death, from the person who actually stabbed his son to
Detective Starsky. And he chose an extremely aggressive way to express his own
fear and grief. Since he couldn't tolerate the loss of his son, he chose to
make someone else pay. This also demonstrates a very immature level of moral
development."
"Thank you, Doctor. Your
witness."
Olin's cross-examination was brief.
"How long have you spent talking to my client, Doctor?"
"I held a two-hour interview
with Mr. Prudholm after I had reviewed his case files, and spent another two
hours with him after administering the tests."
"Why did it take so long to
certify him competent to stand trial, if he's not insane? It's been three years
since Miss Roberts' death."
"Paperwork, counselor,"
Hill said. "The bane of modern existence. I began reviewing his files only
three months ago, and I wanted to be sure. I'm sure."
Olin looked grim. "Nothing
further, your honor."
"Mr. Johnson?" Greanias
said when Olin had sat down.
"Your honor, the county medical
examiner has been called away on a family emergency," Johnson said,
referring to a note in his hand that the bailiff handed to him while Olin was
questioning Dr.Hill. "Request the court's indulgence to call him as a
witness later in the trial. He'll be back tomorrow, and he's my last witness.
Otherwise, the prosecution rests."
"Very well. The court grants
the motion. Mr. Olin, you may call your first witness."
"The defense calls Dr. Henry
Mosier."
A man of about fifty was sworn in as
the next witness. His salt and pepper hair, glasses, and dark suit gave him an
air of professionalism.
"Dr. Mosier, you are a
psychiatrist, is that correct?"
Starsky and Hutch looked at each
other, each realizing why Olin had asked the other doctor so few questions.
They had their own "expert" witness.
"Yes."
"How long have you practiced
psychiatry?"
"Thirty years. Twenty of them
in state institutions and the past ten in private practice."
"Do you have a specialty in the
field of psychiatry?"
"Yes, I specialize in severe
psychotic disorders like schizophrenia and the criminally insane."
"Isn't it true that you have
examined, diagnosed, and treated serial killers?"
"Yes, that's true."
Olin crossed in front of the jury
with his back to the man on the witness stand. "So, is it accurate to
state that you are an expert in your field?"
"Yes."
Olin smiled a little and turned back
to face the witness stand. "Is George Prudholm sane?"
"Objection! That statement is
too broad and therefore the answer could be misleading."
"Overruled."
"No, he is not. I believe Mr.
Prudholm is now, and may always be, insane. He is a dangerous psychotic."
"In your expert opinion, Dr.
Mosier, is George Prudholm responsible for his actions?"
"No."
Starsky was squirming in his seat.
He was jiggling one leg constantly, using it as a tactic to keep his anger and
anxiety in check. His eyes were never still, continually scanning from Hutch,
to the witness, to the defense attorney, to Prudholm, and back to Hutch. He was
worried about his partner and on alert for anything else that might happen.
Hutch's head was pounding and the room
wasn't all that steady for him so his partner's twitchy movements were making
him nauseous. He put a steadying hand on Starsky's knee and shook his head
slightly. His friend settled down and tried to sit still.
"Nothing further." Olin
walked back to the defense table and sat next to his shackled client with a
smug look on his face.
Mark Johnson approached the stand.
"Dr. Mosier, have you been treating the defendant?"
"No, I have not. I have
evaluated him."
"How much time have you spent
with George Prudholm?"
"We met for about thirty
minutes yesterday." Johnson was pleased, seeing a chink in the good
doctor's testimony.
"Your entire exposure to this
man boils down to thirty minutes just yesterday?"
"Well, I did also carefully
review Mr. Prudholm's files and psychiatric history."
"How do you explain the
discrepancy between your opinion and Dr. Hill's?"
"I can only speak for myself.
In my assessment, the man is not responsible for his actions."
"Were you paid to be here
today?"
"Objection! That is irrelevant."
Olin was outraged by the question.
"I disagree, your honor. I wish
to establish that the doctor's opinion may be tarnished by the fact that he was
paid to give it specifically for this trial."
"I'll allow it, but tread
softly here, counselor."
"Yes, I was paid."
"You were 'hired' then to
testify on this man's behalf?"
"I was hired to determine
Prudholm's sanity. That is what I did."
"Dr. Mosier, do you have
regular patients at this time?"
Olin was agitated. He did not expect
the D.A. to know anything about his expert witness. Prudholm's brother had paid
to fly the man in from another state in the hopes that the D.A. would not know
him.
"No, I do not."
"Isn't it true, Doctor, that
you are a professional paid witness?"
"Objection!"
"Overruled."
"I have devoted my time in the
past few years to helping defendants in matters such as these."
"Answer the question, Doctor,
are you a professional paid witness?"
The doctor was angry, Olin was
furious, and Starsky was on the edge of his seat with Hutch's hand on his arm
to remind him to keep his emotions in check.
"Yes."
"Thank you, Doctor. Nothing
further." Johnson sat back down at the prosecution table, but not before
he gave a reassuring nod to Starsky and his battered partner.
Olin sat at the table for several moments,
finally forcing Greanias to say, "Mr. Olin, have you any more
witnesses?"
Olin gave himself a little shake.
"Yes, your honor, I do. The defense calls Woodrow Klein to the
stand."
Klein, better known to Starsky and
Hutch as "Woody the Magic Man," was brought in from the anteroom by
another deputy, who removed his cuffs just before allowing him to be sworn in.
Klein was still serving his own sentence from Terry's death and the robberies
that preceded it.
"Mr. Klein, are you acquainted
with my client?"
Woody nodded. "Yeah. We, uh, we
used to hang out."
"How well do you know him,
sir?"
"Pretty good," Woody said.
"I went to school with Gary."
"Please tell the court about
the incidents in question."
"Huh?"
Olin wet his lips and tried to hide
his impatience. "The robberies and Miss Roberts' death, Mr. Klein."
"Oh. Yeah. Well, George looked
me up about three years ago, when I got out of the joint the last time, and he
said he had a job for us. He wanted me to follow those two," he indicated
Starsky and Hutch, "around and tell him where they went all day. So I did.
I followed 'em for a coupla weeks and got their schedule all wrote down for
George. Then he told me he was gonna make Starsky pay for what happened to
Gary."
"And did he ask you to help
him?"
"Yeah. I said I would, 'cause I
needed some bread, just gettin' outta the joint, ya know, and he said we'd rob
some liquor stores and I could keep most of the loot since he was mostly
interested in gettin' to Starsky."
Olin glanced at Starsky, who had
relaxed somewhat after the doctor's testimony. "Was there anything strange
about my client's behavior during this time, Mr. Klein?"
"Well, yeah. He kept callin' me
'Gary.' I mean, once in a while he'd call me 'Woody,' but mostly he'd call me
'Gary.' I kept tellin' him my name's Woody, but it didn't seem to make no
difference to him. He's a crazy bastard."
"Objection!" Johnson
stood. "Your honor, this man, besides being an incarcerated felon, is not
qualified to make such statements about the defendant's mental health."
"This witness," Olin
countered, "is well-acquainted with the defendant and I am not asking him
for an expert opinion, but for his impressions. I think that's valid."
Greanias nodded. "I'll allow
the statement to stand."
Johnson sat down, but he wasn't happy.
"Why did Prudholm call you by
his son's name?"
"He thought I was Gary,"
Woody said. "He'd say stuff like 'when you were stabbed in jail, Gary' and
I'd say 'I'm not Gary, Gary's dead' and he'd go on talking like I hadn't said
nothin'. It was weird."
"Thank you. Nothing
further."
Johnson stood and walked toward
Woody. "Mr. Klein, tell us what happened the night Miss Roberts was
shot."
"I'd been followin' her around,
too," Woody said. "George saw her with Starsky and wanted to know who
she was. When I figured out she went to that store every night about supper
time to get some milk and a newspaper, I told him and we made that our next
stop."
"And what happened when you
robbed that store?"
Woody looked over at George
nervously and didn't answer immediately.
"Answer the question," the
judge instructed him.
"It's kinda hard, with him
starin' at me like that," Woody said. Starsky looked over at Prudholm, who
was glaring at Woody with absolute hatred.
Johnson moved so that he was between
Woody and Prudholm. "Your answer, Mr. Klein."
Woody took a long drink from his
glass of water. "Well, we waited outside till we saw her go in and then we
followed her. George told me he was gonna pop her "
"Pop her?"
"Shoot her," Woody said.
"Kill her. I was supposed to make like it was a real robbery, you know,
but he said don't make it too good, 'cause he wanted everybody in there to see
that he was just after her. That way they'd tell Starsky and Hutch."
"How did Mr. Prudholm know
Starsky and Hutchinson would answer the call?" Johnson asked.
"It was their beat. And Starsky
knew she went in there every night as well as I did," Woody said. "He
went with her a couple of times while I was followin' her, and I heard him
tease her about it."
Starsky went white to the lips at
that. Hutch had a hand on his arm and could feel the tension there. Starsky
swallowed hard and glanced at his partner. The look in his eyes told Hutch what
he was thinking if he hadn't teased Terry about her regular habits, Woody
might not have known she went into that store every night. And how had he
missed seeing Woody, whom they both knew on sight?
"Go on, please."
"Well, we went in there, and I
stuck up the clerk while George looked around for Terry. She was at the back, by
the cooler where they keep the milk. He hollered at her and she turned around
and he shot her."
"What did he say to her?"
Starsky went very still.
"He said, 'Hey, Terry, aren't
you Starsky's slut?' and she whirled around and opened her mouth, to answer him,
I guess, and that's when he shot her. She fell backward against the cooler and
kind of slid down it to the floor. Me and the guy behind the counter just
watched with our mouths open, and then George turned around to me and said,
'She's dead, let's go.' And I said, 'But what about the money?' and George came
over to the register and opened it and grabbed some of the money and handed it
to me, and we left."
Hutch slid an arm around his
partner's back. Starsky was so pale and his eyes so wide that Hutch was worried
he might pass out.
Johnson glanced at Starsky, then
back to Woody. "Thank you." He sat down and whispered to Starsky,
"Sergeant, do we need to ask for a recess?"
Starsky was trembling, but he shook
his head. Johnson regarded him thoughtfully for several moments before turning
away.
The judge had seen the look on
Starsky's face also. "Mr. Johnson, would you like a recess?"
Johnson glanced back and Hutch shook
his head slightly. "No, your honor."
Greanias considered calling a recess
anyway, but decided against it. He had lost his own wife the same year Terry
died. The judge knew what that loss felt like and still carried the pain of it.
He wanted this trial to keep moving so the torment would be over for the man in
the witness gallery.
"Mr. Olin, call your next
witness."
"The defense calls Eunice
Craig."
Johnson had told the two detectives
that Mrs. Craig had been subpoenaed as a witness for George Prudholm. They
couldn't understand it, but she was now walking up to take the oath and sit on
the witness stand. She looked at Starsky, sadness in her eyes. He wished he
knew what she was thinking.
"Your honor, I will be treating
Mrs. Craig as a hostile witness."
"Very well, Mr. Olin, but stick
to the case."
"Yes, your honor."
"Mrs. Craig, can you tell me
what happened to your son Lonnie Craig?"
"He was shot and killed during
a hold up."
"How old was he at the
time?"
"Lonnie was
sixteen-years-old." Eunice Craig kept glancing back and forth from the
D.A. to Starsky. He gave her a small smile, trying to reassure her. He knew how
uncomfortable it was to be on the stand.
"Who killed your son, Mrs.
Craig?"
"Detective Starsky."
"How did you feel when that
happened?"
"Objection! Mrs. Craig's feelings
about the death of her son have no relevance to these proceedings."
Johnson said.
Olin countered with, "Mrs.
Craig's son died at the hands of the same man responsible for Gary Prudholm's
death. I merely want to establish what it feels like to have a loved one taken
away from you by Sergeant Starsky."
The courtroom buzzed in quiet
murmuring. Starsky's ears started ringing and he felt hot suddenly. Hutch
reached for him, seeing the color drain from his face and whispered,
"Breathe, buddy, it's okay." The judge banged his gavel. "This
court will come to order." The D.A. was about to voice his objections to
Olin's comments when the judge put up a hand to silence him.
The murmuring settled down as the
judge turned a cold eye toward the defense attorney.
"Mr. Olin, you are dangerously
close to contempt. I warned you early on that Sergeant Starsky is not on trial
here and I will not tolerate any further pejorative comments about him from
you. Is that clearly understood?"
Olin swallowed and nervously adjusted
his tie. "Yes, your honor."
"The objection is
sustained."
The defense attorney regrouped.
"Mrs. Craig, when Lonnie died, were you angry with Sergeant Starsky?"
Johnson sat back and decided to let
this line of questioning run for a while, hoping Olin was about to fall into
his own trap.
"I was upset."
"But were you angry?"
Mrs. Craig was quiet. She looked at
Starsky apologetically. "At first, yes."
"Did you blame him?"
"At first."
Olin seemed satisfied and he didn't
want to push the judge. "Nothing further, your witness."
Johnson turned for a moment to look
at the pale man behind him. He was concerned about how much more Starsky could
take and his banged up partner wasn't looking much better. He approached the
witness stand.
"Mrs. Craig, do you still blame
Sergeant Starsky for your son's death?"
"No. Lonnie was trying to shoot
Detective Starsky. He had no choice."
"Have you ever discussed your
son with Sergeant Starsky?
"Yes. He came to see me the day
of Lonnie's funeral."
Johnson paused and looked at the
jury. Pointing to Starsky, he said, "Mrs. Craig, based on that
conversation, what was your impression of how Sergeant Starsky felt about
having to shoot Lonnie in the line of duty?"
Eunice Craig looked at Starsky, her
face soft. "I believe Sergeant Starsky was deeply affected by the
shooting. He only wanted to catch the person responsible for turning Lonnie
bad. I'd say he felt terrible about the whole thing."
Starsky sighed deeply and closed his
eyes. The incident with Lonnie Craig had taken a lot out of him. Hearing Eunice
Craig say that she didn't blame him gave him some peace of mind. He nodded at
her as she passed him on her way out of the court. Mrs. Craig had no desire to
hear any more of the ugliness being brought forth in this trial. She smiled at Starsky
when she saw him nod, hoping he would be all right. She barely knew him and she
could see that he was not doing well.
The judge banged his gavel and
declared the court would be in recess until one o'clock. Prudholm was led away,
but not before he turned to sneer at Starsky. He was about to say something
when his guard roughly turned him back away from Starsky's gaze and shoved him
through the door leading to the holding area.
"You gentlemen doing
okay?" Johnson asked Starsky and Hutch,
"Don't we look okay?"
Hutch quipped.
"Frankly, no."
Starsky had made no move to get up
from his seat. He was leaning on the banister between the two men and Johnson.
Hutch said, "Uh, why don't you hit it, Johnson. My partner and I are gonna
wait here for a bit."
Johnson knew when he was being
dismissed. He gathered his things and left the courtroom.
"Starsk?"
"I'm okay. I just need to sit
here for a minute."
Hutch nodded and winced a little
from the sudden sharp pain in his head.
Starsky stood up and said, "I'm
sorry, Hutch. I forgot your pills." He walked to the prosecution table and
poured Hutch some water. Handing the glass to Hutch, he fished in his pocket
for the pain pills.
"Thanks, Starsk."
Hutch noticed Starsky's color was a
little better. "Let's go get some lunch. You name the place."
"You planning to eat?"
"Nah, my head hurts. I'll just
watch."
"You've gotta eat, Hutch."
"Maybe when I'm sure the room
won't start spinning again."
Starsky was concerned. "You
feelin' dizzy still?"
"A little. Nothing to worry about,
Gordo. Let just get out of here. Slowly, okay?"
Each of them was keeping a wary eye
on the other as they left the courtroom. Starsky stopped at the doors to peek
out before they left just to be sure they were not going to be bombarded by
reporters again. The hallway was empty. They quietly walked down it and slipped
out the back door, just to be sure.
"It's almost over, buddy,"
Hutch said when they were seated at Huggy's. It's where Starsky had wanted to
go, and though Hutch suspected that was so they'd be safe from prying eyes
the trial was front-page news, complete with photos of both of them, God knows
where the press had found the photos in question he also knew that Starsky
probably figured Huggy would find some way to tempt Hutch to eat.
"Prudholm's gotta be
next," Starsky said.
"Surely even Olin isn't stupid
enough to let him testify, even if he wants to," Hutch objected.
"I'll bet he does
testify," Starsky said. "He's dyin' to get up there and tell us all
how much he enjoyed " he stopped.
Hutch put a hand on his arm and they
sat in silence until Huggy could get away from his other customers and come
over to them.
"You two look like hell,"
he said without preamble. "Pretty ugly, huh?"
Hutch nodded.
Huggy studied them for a moment.
"Well, my friends, you came to the right place." He drew a Dr. Pepper
out of the cooler for Starsky and set a small bottle of orange juice in front
of Hutch. "Be right back," he said, vanishing through the door to the
kitchen.
He came back in a few minutes and placed
a chef salad in front of Hutch and a pastrami sandwich in front of Starsky.
"Eat," he said. "I'll stand here and make ya if I have to."
Hutch grinned a little wanly.
"Thanks, Mom."
Huggy snorted. "If I was your
mama, I'd send you both home to bed for a good long nap. Since I ain't, I'll
just make sure you eat. You ain't eatin'," he added pointedly.
Though neither of them had much
appetite, they did manage to force some of it down while Huggy watched
approvingly. And they did feel a bit better afterwards.
"Now," Huggy said,
"when you get done at that courthouse this afternoon, both of you come
back here and Huggy'll have you a coupla steaks on the grill. I ain't gonna
stand here and watch my two favorite cops waste away over some scum like Crazy
George."
Starsky opened his mouth, but Huggy
raised one hand.
"Don't argue with me, Curly. I
got a club in the back."
Even Starsky grinned at that. And
surrendered. "Okay, Hug. Don't get violent. We'll be here about 5."
"Good. Now scat. I got other customers,
you know."
~*~*~*~
The moment Starsky and Hutch had
most been dreading had arrived. George Prudholm was about to take the stand.
Olin had tried unsuccessfully throughout the trial to convince Prudholm that
testifying in his own behalf was a bad idea. His decision had opened the door
for his prior history being brought into the court. The man was adamant. Olin
was worried that Prudholm would say or do something that would prejudice the
jury against him even more than the previous days in court had.
Olin went to the judge during recess
and asked that he have the two police officers barred from the rest of the
proceedings. He stated they were disrupting the flow of the trial and diverting
focus away from the facts. Especially Hutchinson, with his battered face a
constant reminder to the jury of what Prudholm had done too close to what had
happened to the victim in this case. When Hutchinson was shot, Olin was not too
distracted to notice the look of anguish and sheer terror on Starsky's face as
he raced to the fallen man's side. Olin prayed the jury had not seen it. That
look might be enough to get his client convicted. The judge refused his
request.
The judge was seated and the court
called to order. "Mr. Olin, call your next witness."
"The defense calls George
Prudholm."
Hutch had a hand on Starsky's arm
and he felt him tense beneath it. They watched as Prudholm was assisted to the
stand by the guard who was now never farther from the man than two feet. He
shuffled from the defense table to the witness box. The guard assisted him in
climbing the steps and sitting in the witness chair. The jury watched with
fascination.
Hutch couldn't help marveling at the
irony of making a guy like Prudholm swear to anything with his hand on the
Bible. He was convinced Prudholm was a sadistic, evil man. A man who commits
cold-blooded murder out of unadulterated hatred for another would probably have
little difficulty lying under any circumstances.
Olin began his questioning, first
saying a silent prayer that his client would remain focused. "Mr.
Prudholm, did you shoot Teresa Roberts?"
Prudholm looked past the attorney
and made eye contact with Starsky. His own eyes were filled with icy hatred.
"Yeah. I did."
"Why did you do it, Mr.
Prudholm?" Olin had his fingers crossed and he hoped his client would give
him the right answer.
"Starsky had to pay. Pay for
Gary. The voices told me that he had to pay."
"What voices?"
"The ones that tell me how to
punish Starsky."
Hutch watched Prudholm's face
closely. He could tell the man was putting on an act. He didn't hear any
voices.
"Tell me what kinds of things
the voices tell you." Olin continued.
"Oh, they know all about
Starsky. He's evil. They want him dead more than I do." Prudholm's
malevolent smile leeched into Hutch's psyche. The man still had his eyes locked
with Starsky's.
Hutch didn't like it. He wanted
Starsky to look away, avert his eyes from this man as if his evil could somehow
harm Starsky from across the room. Hutch gave his best friend's arm a slight
shake, trying to distract him without success. His partner gave him no sign of
a reaction. Starsky felt like he was standing at one end of a long tunnel.
Staring into the darkness, he could see Prudholm in the distance at the other
end. Everyone and everything else was blurry on the periphery of Starsky's
vision. The only thing anchoring him in reality was the warm presence of
Hutch's hand on his arm.
"Mr. Prudholm, when did you
start hearing these voices?" Olin was pleased. Prudholm was sounding
pretty crazy, but not too overdone.
"When Gary died. They started
telling me about how Starsky killed my son."
"What else do the voices say,
Mr. Prudholm?"
"Starsky has to suffer. Then he
can die and go to hell where he belongs."
Olin took a deep breath. He wanted
to push for a little more. "At the time of the shooting, did you
understand that you were committing a murder?"
"I didn't see it that way. She
was just another little tramp who could be eliminated to make Starsky
pay."
Hutch felt a shiver go up his back.
He hated the thought of his partner being the object of Prudholm's sick
obsession. He looked at Starsky. Once again his face was ashen and sweaty, his
eyes wide, and his body trembling. Hutch saw the seething anger in his
partner's eyes. He squeezed Starsky's arm and willed him to look away from
Prudholm. Look at me, buddy. Don't look at him. His message was not getting through to
Starsky.
Olin was concerned Prudholm would go
too far. He decided to rest on that note and bring him back for the finale on
redirect if necessary.
"Nothing further for this
witness at this time, your honor." He turned toward Johnson. "Your
witness."
"Mr. Prudholm," Johnson
said with exaggerated politeness, "isn't it true that you told Detective
Starsky that you were confident the courts would find you insane when it came
time to answer for the murder of Miss Roberts?"
"Sure, I told him that,"
Prudholm said with a shrug. "I was right, too."
Johnson checked to make sure the jury
had heard that. They had. So had Olin, whose face had gone a dull red. Keeping
his face impassive, Johnson asked, "Why do you blame Detective Starsky for
the murder of your son, when he was nowhere near your son at the time of his
death?"
"He arrested him, didn't he?
He's the one put him in jail. If he hadn't, Gary wouldn't be dead."
"But if Gary hadn't broken the
law, he wouldn't have been arrested, Mr. Prudholm. Did you consider that?"
"It was a frame," Prudholm
said. "They were at that high school on purpose to bust somebody and they
picked Gary."
"They did catch him with a
pocket full of LSD, sir."
Prudholm shrugged again. "Docs
used to prescribe that. Wasn't illegal not that long ago. Stupid law."
"So, do you believe that if a
law is 'stupid,' you don't have to obey it?"
"Too damn many laws,
anyway," Prudholm muttered, but loud enough to be heard.
"Your honor, I fail to see the
purpose of this line of questioning!" Olin was on his feet, and even from
across the room, the sweat at his hairline was visible.
"I am trying to establish
whether the defendant understands that when one commits a crime, one is
punished," Johnson said.
"Overruled," Greanias said
to Olin.
"Sir, do you understand that
whether you like a law or not, if you break it, the police might arrest you and
the courts might punish you?"
"Not if you're crazy,"
Prudholm said.
"I believe you have served time
in prison before, sir? Is that correct?"
"Yeah, and I didn't wanna go
back," Prudholm said.
"So did you intentionally
attempt to appear mentally impaired so as to avoid going back?"
Prudholm narrowed his eyes and
finally looked away from Starsky to look at Johnson. "I told ya. The
voices told me Starsky had to pay. And the best way to make him pay was to take
everyone and everything he loved away from him, like he took Gary from
me!"
"And so you deliberately set
out to kill the people Detective Starsky loved?"
"Yeah." Prudholm gave an
evil sneer and locked eyes with Starsky again. "I only got to his slut,
though. Missed when I tried to get his blond partner. Missed twice. I won't
miss next time."
"Objection, your honor!"
"Sit down, Mr. Olin.
Overruled."
"Why did you feel you had to
kill Miss Roberts, whom you didn't even know?"
"Starsky loved her,"
Prudholm said, still staring at Starsky. "Tell ya somethin', though. I
kinda hated to do it."
"Why?"
Prudholm grinned. "She was real
pretty. Coulda had more fun with her, if we'd'a pinned her somewhere private.
Soft skin, she had, and a real nice pair of "
Starsky shot to his feet, his eyes
wild, and Hutch grabbed his arm and tried to force him to sit down, though his
own stomach roiled at what Prudholm had said.
The judge banged his gavel.
"Order in the court! Sit down, Detective, or I'll have to find you in
contempt!"
"Starsk, sit down. He's lying,
he never touched her, you heard Woody's testimony," Hutch hissed.
Starsky was trembling violently, but
he forced himself to look away from Prudholm and, at last, sat down.
Johnson was watching and decided he'd
better quit before Starsky blew. He had been perilously close to it for days,
already.
"Nothing further, your
honor."
After Prudholm was returned to the
defense table Olin addressed the court. "The defense rests, your
honor."
The judge nodded. "This court
is in recess until nine o'clock tomorrow for the medical examiner's testimony,
followed by closing arguments." He banged the gavel.
As everyone else started to move in
the direction they needed to take, Starsky sat in his chair, perfectly still.
His hands were gripping the railing in front of him. Hutch looked at him with
deep concern. Starsky's face was gray and he was still shaking. Thankfully, he
was oblivious to everyone's stares as they left. Hutch hoped he was also
oblivious to the things Prudholm was saying to him as they hauled him out of
the courtroom.
Captain Dobey had been sitting near
the back and he was making his way toward his detectives through the exiting
crowd.
"You like that, cop? She was
sure pretty!" Prudholm shouted.
The guards shoved him roughly,
"Shut up and move it!" They were trying their best to get him out
quickly, but his ankles were in chains and he couldn't move very fast.
"Too bad I didn't get to know
her better! Hurts, don't it?"
The two guards picked Prudholm up
under the arms and hustled him out the door, still screaming over his shoulder
at Starsky, "I hope the pain kills you, pig!"
Hutch was trying to get his
partner's attention. He had one hand on Starsky's back and the other on his arm
as he spoke to him gently.
"Starsk?"
No reaction.
"Buddy, you all right?"
This time the reaction was that
Starsky started to shake even worse. He stood up suddenly and took a couple of
steps into the aisle. Then, before Hutch could react he stopped and went down
to the floor as if his legs wouldn't hold him. He was sitting on the floor now
with his head down, shaking violently.
Dobey had reached out for him, but
he wasn't close enough either. He knelt beside him and said, "Dave, you
okay?"
Hutch looked at Dobey with pain and
worry in his eyes. He silently hoped there was a special corner in hell just
for George Prudholm. He knelt on the other side of his partner, putting an arm
around his shoulders.
"Starsky, breathe, okay, buddy?
Just sit there a minute."
Hutch was afraid his friend would
pass out and he was ready for it. Starsky just sat there, his eyes tightly
shut, saying nothing. Hutch could tell he was struggling to get his breathing
under control before he hyperventilated.
A couple of uniformed officers had
also been in the back of the courtroom and they were approaching the three men
slowly. Dobey stood up and barked at them, "You two get outside those
doors and keep everybody out of here!" They instantly obeyed him, making
it to the doors just as the first of the reporters was trying to get into the
courtroom. They shoved him back outside before his cameraman had a chance to
focus on Starsky.
Dobey looked down at Hutch. "He
gonna be okay, Hutch?"
Hutch nodded. "I think it's the
adrenaline, Cap. He'll be okay in a few minutes."
"I'm going to go call for some
more uniforms to hustle those reporters out of here. Give me the keys to the
Torino. I'll bring it around back so you can take him out that way."
Hutch tossed his keys to the
captain, nodding his thanks, then he sat next to Starsky on the floor. They
were the only two people left in the courtroom.
"Starsk? Talk to me,
buddy."
Starsky felt like Hutch was talking
to him from far away. He heard Hutch's voice over the buzzing in his ears and
he reached out a hand for him. He felt Hutch take his hand and allowed it to
anchor him. When he finally spoke, Hutch was worried about how weak his voice
sounded.
"Why, Hutch?"
Hutch's heart twisted. He hated to
see Starsky suffer any more at the hands of George Prudholm. "I don't
know, Gordo. Hey, try to relax, huh?"
Starsky nodded. He opened his eyes,
unhappy with the dark fuzziness around the edges of his vision. He couldn't
remember the last time he had been so angry and he had nowhere for that anger
to go.
"Hutch?" he said weakly as
he started to slump against his partner.
"Stay with me, Starsk. You're
okay!" Hutch gave him a gentle shake and supported his weight, willing him
to stay conscious. He was afraid for his partner. Prudholm was evil and he
prayed his words didn't have enough power to push his friend over the edge.
The next thing Starsky said chilled
him. "I want him to die, Hutch."
"I know, Starsk. I do
too."
They sat together until Starsky's
rapid breathing and pulse slowed. Finally, Dobey came back in and said,
"Hutch, the car's around back and the uniforms have the hallways cleared.
We'd better get him out of here while we can."
Hutch was pretty sure Starsky would
be okay to move. The shaking was much better . "Buddy, we've got to get
out of here now. Can you get up?"
Starsky nodded. Dobey and Hutch
helped him to unsteady feet and slowly walked him out of the courtroom. They
were grateful to see that the reporters were not waiting for them at the back
entrance. The uniforms had done their job well. One of them opened the back
door for the three men and watched Hutch deposit his shaky partner into the
passenger seat of the Torino.
"Thanks, Cap. I'm taking him to
my place. Maybe the reporters won't think to go there. I'll call you
later."
Hutch was glad he had been right. No
reporters greeted them when he pulled the Torino up at Venice Place. Starsky
seemed a little better. Hutch took him up the stairs and tried to walk him into
the bedroom, but Starsky put his arm out to stop him.
"No, I don't want to sleep,
Hutch."
"You should, buddy. Let that
adrenaline rush wear off a bit."
Starsky shook his head and moved
toward the couch. After he was settled, Hutch went and got him a glass of ice
water.
"If you want, I'll send Huggy
over to your place to get you one of those sleeping pills."
"No, thanks. I just want to sit
here with you. Oh, God, Hutch, why do I let him get to me like that?"
Hutch could tell his friend was
feeling weak and embarrassed. "You're being really strong, Starsk. He
could get to anyone."
"I don't want to feel like
this. Just hurts so much."
Starsky looked up at Hutch, just
noticing how tired he looked. "Hey, why don't you go lie down for a
while?"
"Nope. I think I'll stay in
here with you."
"How's your head?"
"Better, thanks. Don't worry
about me. I'm okay."
Starsky smiled at him. That's
funny. Don't worry about him. "Aren't we a pair today?"
"Yeah, but a pair of
what?" Hutch smiled, glad to see Starsky was getting better.
"This'll all be over soon. You
know he's gonna get the death penalty."
"God, I hope so. What if that
insanity thing works, Hutch?"
Hutch tried to sound confident.
"It won't. No way. He knew exactly what he was doing. The jury could see that."
Starsky nodded wearily and put his
head back, closing his eyes. Hutch waited quietly for a few minutes to see if
his friend would drop off to sleep. Despite his best intentions, Starsky did
fall asleep quickly. Hutch could tell he was really out of it, so he picked
Starsky's feet up and laid his legs out on the couch. Then he quietly slipped
into his room to lie down for a while himself. He set his alarm to be sure he
woke up in time to take Starsky to dinner at Huggy's, even though he knew his
friend would probably be unable to eat anything.
Huggy had made them the steaks, as
promised, but neither of them felt much like eating, and only tried because
Huggy stood over them and insisted. Neither of them slept much that night,
either. Every time Starsky woke up, usually due to a nightmare, he could hear
Hutch tossing and turning on the sofa. And every time Hutch woke from one his
infrequent, restless dozes, he could hear Starsky doing the same thing.
Both were hollow-eyed by the time
they reached the courthouse the next morning. Johnson looked them over with
concern.
"We're almost finished," Johnson
said softly. "Hang on for a couple more hours."
Starsky nodded. "We've made it
this far, counselor. We'll be okay."
The medical examiner was in the
courtroom and Johnson rose as soon as the judge had called the proceedings to
order. "Your honor, my last witness is here now."
"You may call him,"
Greanias said.
After he'd been sworn in, Johnson
asked, "Dr. Lynch, did you personally perform the autopsy on Terry
Roberts?"
"Yes, I did."
"Please tell the court what
your findings were."
Hutch reached over to squeeze
Starsky's hand. This wasn't going to be easy.
"Miss Roberts had a .45 caliber
bullet lodged in the frontal lobe," Lynch said. "The bullet entered
through her forehead at the hairline and turned as it entered, stopping just
inside the skull, according to her medical records. When I examined her body,
the bullet had worked its way deeper into her brain and interrupted the
involuntary functions such as sight and sense of touch, and eventually,
heartbeat."
Starsky's eyes were full of tears.
Hutch squeezed his hand again, but Starsky didn't look at him.
"Did Miss Roberts suffer,
Doctor?"
Lynch, who knew both Starsky and
Hutch, hesitated. Finally, he said, "It's difficult to be certain. The
brain is an organ science has yet to fully understand. But based on what we do
know, I would say her pain at the time the injury was inflicted was quite
severe. From that point, it would come and go. At the end, the original
severity of the pain probably returned, but only for the last few moments of
life."
"Do you concur with Dr. Quo and
her colleagues that nothing could have been done to save Miss Roberts'
life?"
Lynch nodded. "Yes, I do.
Frankly, I'm surprised she lived as long as she did, and apparently she lived
with every appearance of normality during much of that time."
"Thank you, Doctor. Your
witness, Mr. Olin."
"No questions," Olin said,
surprising both Starsky and Hutch.
"Very well," Greanias
said. "Then we are ready to hear closing arguments. Mr. Johnson?"
Johnson rose and walked to the jury
box. He stopped in front of it and leaned against the rail on his hands, making
eye contact with every person in it before speaking. "Ladies and
gentlemen, you have seen for yourselves the damage the defendant has inflicted.
With cold, calculating malice, this man set out to seek revenge against
Detective David Starsky for an act that Detective Starsky did not commit the
death of Gary Prudholm.
"During this man's vendetta
against Detective Starsky, he murdered two police officers: Dan Tinker, who had
a wife and two small children; Steve Kelton, who graduated at the top of his
class in the police academy and had only been on the force nine months.
"He assaulted Mr. Brown, a
close friend of both Detectives Starsky and Hutchinson, simply because he is
their friend. He attempted to murder Detective Hutchinson, once with a rigged
shotgun and the second time right here in front of this entire courtroom. He
attempted to murder Detective Starsky by ambushing him in the old city zoo.
"And he murdered Teresa Renee
Roberts in cold blood in front of witnesses.
"And all because he blames
Detective Starsky for the death of Gary Prudholm, who was killed in a fight
which he himself started in the county jail! Ladies and gentlemen, I appeal to
your integrity. This man has destroyed the lives of Officer Tinker's family,
Officer Kelton's family, Detective Starsky and Teresa Roberts' family! He is a
cold-blooded, heartless and unrepentant killer. You cannot let him go free. You
cannot believe for one moment that this man is mentally impaired beyond the
ability to know right from wrong. He knew exactly what he was doing and he did
it anyway. He admitted, in fact, he bragged to Detective Starsky that he had no
fear of punishment because he was confident the courts would find him insane! A
man who is truly insane does not realize that fact. This man is not insane,
ladies and gentlemen! He is a murderer, as sane as you or I, and he murdered
Teresa Roberts as a malevolent act of revenge.
"You must find him guilty. You
have no choice. Look at Detective Starsky. Look at Detective Hutchinson."
All twelve members of the jury
obeyed. Starsky had endured so much already and had managed to maintain his
composure during court so far, but when Johnson appealed to the jury in this
manner, and they were all looking at him, it was just too much. A tear streaked
down his cheek, and Hutch instinctively put an arm around his shoulders for
support. Starsky looked down and covered his face with one hand.
Johnson looked back at the jury and
saw empathy on every face. He went on, "These men, and the other people
who have suffered at the hands of George Prudholm, deserve no less than the
peace of mind you can offer them by putting this man where he can do no more
harm. It is in your hands."
Johnson sat down.
Olin strolled over to the jury box
and gave Johnson a pitying smile as he passed. He put his hands in his pockets
and gazed at the jury. "Very appealing arguments my esteemed colleague has
offered you," Olin said. "I applaud him. Really, I do. But, ladies
and gentlemen, my colleague is appealing to your emotions, not your reason. I
appeal to your reason. Yes, Detectives Starsky and Hutchinson have suffered. I
sympathize. But my client is not a sane man. A sane man would not blame a
police officer for the death of his son to the point that he would plan and
execute systematic revenge such as my client has. If my client was sane, he
might be angry that Detective Starsky arrested his son and that that arrest was
the reason Gary Prudholm was in jail to be killed in a fight. But a sane man
would not accuse the officer of murder, which my client has done repeatedly.
"George Prudholm is sick,
ladies and gentlemen. He is sick the same as if he had cancer or kidney disease
or diabetes. He needs treatment for that illness, not prison. In prison, he
will be punished, it is true. And yes, sending him to prison will no doubt give
the people he has harmed a measure of peace.
"But you cannot punish a man
for being ill. That would fly in the face of the principles this country was
founded upon. Would you send a cancer patient to prison for having cancer? Of
course not! He cannot help having this illness any more than a cancer patient
can help having his illness. And he is not legally responsible for his
actions."
Johnson stood again to offer his
parting comments.
"Ladies and Gentlemen, my
colleague is correct, sick men cannot be held legally responsible for their
actions. However, as you have heard from the testimony of an expert, and based
on the observations of the witnesses, George Prudholm is just as sane as you
are. His calculating plans to harm Detective David Starsky, his friends, and
his loved ones are a perfect example of this. Mr. Prudholm murdered Teresa
Roberts with malice aforethought, lying in wait for her. He knew exactly what
he was doing and he executed elaborate schemes to get his way. He nearly killed
Detective Kenneth Hutchinson right here in this room before your eyes. This
unremorseful man deserves to be punished for his crimes and thereby kept from
inflicting more harm on anyone else. I trust you will see that and find in the
State's favor." Johnson was quiet and he returned to his seat.
The courtroom was hushed as the
judge waited a few moments to let the prosecutor's words hang in the air. Then
he turned to the jury and gave them their instructions. They were escorted out
and court was recessed for the duration of jury deliberation. One of Prudholm's
guards looked back to where Starsky and Hutch were sitting, seeing the pain on
Starsky's face. Hutch was leaning close to him, talking quietly.
The guard stepped closer to Prudholm
and leaned down to whisper to him before helping him to his feet. "I swear
to God, Prudholm, you say one word and I'll put you out, you got that?"
Prudholm looked ready to give him a
smart answer as he tried to lean back and catch Starsky's gaze. The other guard
blocked his view and nodded at him, the intent clearly etched on his face. Both
guards had moved their hands to their nightsticks. George Prudholm smiled wryly
and let the two guards help him to his feet. Turning around one more time in
the hope of making eye contact with Starsky, he found Captain Dobey blocking
his view this time. Dejectedly thinking that these men were all taking the fun
out of his day he wisely kept his mouth shut and was escorted out of the
courtroom without incident.
Hutch had been speaking to Starsky
soothingly. He was worried about his friend, knowing that he was near the end
of his rope. Starsky was quiet again. So quiet even Captain Dobey was afraid
for him.
Johnson had walked up to the three
men and put his hand on Captain Dobey's arm to get his attention. "He
going to be all right, Captain?"
He wasn't sure what he was reading
in Captain Dobey's eyes anger, defiance, or frustration. Dobey looked at him
and said, "You know, Johnson, I understand why you did what you just did,
but was it necessary to try and win at his expense?" The captain jerked
his head back toward Starsky and Johnson was certain the look was anger.
"I'm sorry, Captain. I
certainly don't want to do anything to harm Detective Starsky. You're right,
though. I would have said anything to convince that jury that Prudholm has to
be found guilty. I'm sorry if that hurt him, but he'll get over it. He'll feel
much better when he knows Prudholm is on death row."
Hearing that, Hutch's head snapped
up and he stood, towering menacingly over the shorter attorney. He put one
finger on Johnson's chest and said, "Well, I hope you're satisfied. You
used him to elicit sympathy from the jury without any thought for what it would
do to him. You've done that throughout this trial. All I can say for you is
you'd better win. I hope it was worth it."
Johnson swallowed hard. He wasn't
easily intimidated, but the tall blond's look of cold fury was enough to
intimidate almost anyone.
"I'm sorry, Detective
Hutchinson. I never wanted to hurt him, but you're right. Sometimes we have to
play dirty to win against this scum. You live your life to take them off the
streets. I live mine to make sure they get justice. It's what I do."
Dobey put his hand on Hutch's arm
and gently pushed him back from his hostile stance. "Take care of your
partner, Hutch," he said quietly. Hutch looked at his captain and nodded,
sitting back down with Starsky. After Captain Dobey instructed him to call the
instant the jury was back, Johnson finished gathering his papers and walked out
of the courtroom.
Starsky didn't make eye contact with
Hutch. He knew he would lose it if he did, so he stared straight ahead when he
asked, "How long?"
Hutch looked up at Dobey who
shrugged and he said, "No way to tell, partner. Come on, let's get you out
of here."
Starsky shook his head. "No, I
want to stay until they're done."
Dobey said, "Dave, they could
be deliberating for hours, maybe even overnight. Let Hutch take you home."
Starsky didn't argue or resist them
as they helped him to his feet. Hutch asked, "Cap, what about the
reporters?"
"It's taken care of, Hutch.
We'll take him out the back like we did yesterday." He offered Hutch his
keys. "Give me your keys and take my car. You take off out of here in the
Torino and every reporter in the city is going to follow you. They fell for
that yesterday, but they won't two days in a row. My car's at the back
door."
"Thanks, Cap."
"You going to your place?"
Hutch thought about it for a minute,
stealing a look at his trembling partner. "No, Cap. I have a better idea.
I'll call you. Page me if they come back before then, okay?"
Dobey nodded and watched as Hutch
led Starsky away down the hall toward the back entrance to the court.
Starsky didn't notice he was being
put into Dobey's car instead of his own and that worried Hutch. He expected at
least to be questioned about how the Torino was going to make it out of the
courthouse parking lot on its own.
"Hey, buddy, aren't you worried
about your car?" He asked, trying to put a hint of humor in his strained
voice.
Starsky shook his head and quietly
said, "Sure you took care of it."
Oh boy, this is not good. Hutch put his hand on Starsky's shoulder
reassuringly. Starsky felt the warmth of his touch and took some comfort in it.
He was so tired and he wanted it to be finished. He looked out the window and
noticed they were not headed toward either of their homes and Huggy's was in
the opposite direction.
"Hey, Blintz. Where are we
goin'?" he asked.
"Oh, you'll see. I have an
idea." Hutch replied.
"Oh, an idea. Well, let's have
it."
"You'll see, just sit back and
relax, Gordo."
A few minutes later they pulled into
the parking lot of the miniature golf course the two of them had taken their
girlfriends to so many times when Terry was still alive. Starsky looked around
incredulously and said, "Hutch, this isn't such a good idea."
"Trust me a minute, okay?"
"Just a minute? Like I don't
always." Starsky shook his head, wondering what was going on inside his
partner's mind.
Hutch walked him in and led him to a
bench. "Wait here, I'll be right back."
When Hutch walked up to the young
lady running the concessions, she took one look at his bruised face, complete
with black eye and whistled. After he explained what he wanted she shook her
head, pointed at his battered face, and said, "Mister, you didn't get that
here did you?"
"What?" As soon as he said
it he realized she meant his injuries. He laughed and said, "No,
sweetheart, you wouldn't believe me if I told you how I got this. Don't worry,
I'm not goin' in there, my friend is."
She took his money, handing him the
equipment and a cup full of tokens, and gave him a sly smile. "Bet you're
pretty cute when you don't look like you ran face first into a wall."
"Thanks."
Hutch walked back to his best friend
who looked up at him in disbelief. He was standing there holding a baseball bat
and helmet. Hutch said, "Batting cages, buddy."
"You've got to be kidding,
Hutch. I don't have the energy. Just take me home, huh?"
"Nope. Batting cages
first."
"What if the jury comes back
while we're here?" Starsky asked.
Hutch patted his pocket, "I
have a pager, Dobey will let us know."
Hutch grabbed Starsky under the
elbow and led him to the cages. He wanted to give his friend the chance to work
off some of his frustration, hoping it would snap him out of the depression
that was starting to scare Hutch. He tried to steer Starsky toward the slow-pitch
softball cage, but Starsky stopped.
"Oh, no you don't. If I'm gonna
do this, that one." Starsky pointed to the fastest speed cage. The one
that said you had to be at least a college level ballplayer to go into it.
"Starsk . . . ."
Starsky's look told him he would
brook no argument. Hutch handed him the equipment and stepped aside, taking
Starsky's jacket and tie from him. When Starsky was in position and set, Hutch
put in the tokens to start the pitching machine. Then he stood back to watch
and hoped this was a good idea.
The pitches were fast, at least 80
mph. Starsky couldn't get his bat around fast enough and pitch after pitch
sailed past him. He was too close to the center of the plate.
"Starsk, you're crowding the
plate." Hutch called through the fence.
The next pitch was a little wider
for some reason. Starsky was leaning into it and the ball hit him squarely on
the helmet, spinning it off his head as he fell to the ground.
"Starsky!" Hutch shouted.
He had no way to stop the pitching machine and he stood back a moment, waiting
for the interval between pitches to open the door and go check on Starsky. By
the time he got inside the batting cage, Starsky was sitting up, swearing in
both English and some other language Hutch thought must be Russian or Polish,
and shaking his head.
He pulled Starsky back a little
farther away from the pitches and looked him in the eyes. "You okay?"
He said, the fear in his voice clearly conveyed.
Starsky shook him off saying,
"Yeah, I'm all right." The pitches had stopped. "Go put some
more tokens in that thing."
Hutch shook his head, "Oh, no,
this was a bad idea. Come on, let's get out of here."
Starsky was angry. "Hutch, I
said put some more tokens in that thing."
His buddy didn't seem to be hurt,
just mad. Hutch reluctantly agreed. He gave Starsky the Hutchinson finger and
said, "All right, but you put that helmet back on and quit crowding the
plate."
Starsky did as he was told. This
time, his anger helped him to hit his stride. He connected with pitch after pitch.
Each hit seemed to drain away some of the anger he had bottled up inside him.
Hutch kept feeding the machine tokens as long as Starsky looked like he needed
it. Finally, Starsky stepped back, sweaty and exhausted. He put his hand up to
convey the message that he was done.
He stepped out of the batting cage
and grinned at his partner. "Thanks, buddy. How'd you know that would make
me feel better?"
Hutch shrugged. "Just a
hunch."
They walked out to return the equipment,
Starsky feeling better, and Hutch a lot less worried. His mind was racing as he
tried to figure out what to do next to occupy his partner until the jury
returned.
"Are you hungry?"
"As a matter of fact,"
Starsky said with some surprise, "I am. Where's the nearest butterfly
bones store?"
Hutch chuckled. "I was thinking
more along the lines of burritos, pal. What d'you say to that?"
Starsky narrowed his eyes. "Are
you sick?"
"No," Hutch said, holding
his hands up in surrender. "I can eat a burrito once in a while, you
know."
There was a little Mexican
drive-through place on their beat that Hutch knew Starsky was fond of, so they
went there. Hutch watched, pleased, as Starsky devoured two beef-and-bean
burritos, a taco and a large Dr. Pepper. He could see his partner's color
improve even as he watched. He ate a taco salad himself, and felt much better
afterwards.
"Okay, Hutch," Starsky
said as he gathered up their trash and wadded it into a ball. "What are we
going to do now?"
"What do you mean?"
Starsky shook his head. "How
many years've we known each other? And you think I can't read ya like a book?
You're keepin' me busy so I won't think about what the jury's talkin' about
back there."
Hutch had no answer for that, and
Starsky's eyes crinkled in the first real grin he'd produced since the trial
started.
"I was right."
"Well, there isn't anything we
can do to hurry things along," Hutch began, but Starsky waved a hand.
"I know. So how about a movie?
We could catch the cheapo matinee," he added, looking down at his watch.
"Not porn," Hutch said.
"No, a real movie."
The jury still hadn't come back by
the time the movie was over, and it was getting dark out.
"I have a bad feeling they may
be in there all night," Starsky said with a sigh, looking at his watch
again.
"It's a serious thing,
sentencing a man to die," Hutch said gently. "I'd want to think about
it a while, too."
"Yeah, I guess." Starsky
said. "Now what? I thought of the movie."
Hutch grinned. "So it's my turn
again. Huggy's?"
But Starsky shook his head.
"I'm kinda wiped, buddy. Let's just go home, huh? Play chess or watch a
late movie or something."
"Okay."
They went to Starsky's this time,
because Hutch was afraid the reporters might have staked out his own place by
now. It was deserted except for a marked car parked outside with two officers
inside. Both men approached it.
"Evening, fellas," Starsky
said.
"Hi, Starsky, Hutch. You guys
doing okay?" The driver was Matt Becker, with his partner Joe Briggs, both
from their precinct.
"Yeah," Hutch said,
"but what are you doing here?"
"Dobey's orders," Briggs
said. "'Keep the media away or die trying' were his exact words if memory
serves." He grinned.
Starsky and Hutch glanced at each
other. And both smiled.
Three chess games and an hour and a half
with Johnny Carson later, the pager still had not gone off. Hutch was trying to
stifle his yawns when Starsky stretched and said, "Face it, buddy, they
ain't coming back tonight. We might as well crash."
"Sure, Starsk."
Both were so exhausted by the strain
they'd been under, that they slept through the night without any more bad
dreams. When Hutch woke at last, it was the middle of the morning. Starsky was
still sacked out, snoring. Hutch gave an affectionate smile at the sight and
padded into the kitchen to start breakfast. He had just dished it up and was on
his way to wake Starsky when the pager beeped.
Hutch froze mid-step, looked down at
the pager, then took a deep breath. He went into Starsky's bedroom and touched
his partner's shoulder. "Jury's back."
The two men quickly dressed in their
court clothes and rushed downtown to be there for the reading of the verdict.
The court was set to convene at eleven. As they walked into the courtroom and
took their seats next to Captain Dobey they both noticed the hushed atmosphere
in the room and that all eyes were on them as they entered. When both men were
seated, Captain Dobey gave them a reassuring smile. He noted to himself that
the dark-haired detective had lost his habit of going to the men's room just before
the reading of a verdict. He wondered whether that was his idea, or
Hutchinson's.
Johnson turned around to greet them,
hoping they were not still angry about his closing remarks. "You two up
for this?" he asked.
Both detectives nodded. Starsky added,
"Johnson, whatever goes down, I know you did your best."
"Thanks, Starsky."
The defendant was brought into the
courtroom in his shackles. Everyone turned to watch as the jury filed in from
the side door. Hutch was desperately trying to get a read on them, but he had
no idea. The bailiff stepped forward and said, "All rise. Court is now in
session. The honorable Judge Joseph Greanias presiding."
When the judge and everyone else was
seated, the judge turned to the jury. "Have you reached a verdict in the matter
before you?"
The foreman stood. "We have,
your honor."
"Please hand the verdict to the
bailiff."
The bailiff took the piece of paper
and walked it over to the judge. Starsky was holding his breath, sweat starting
to bead on his upper lip. Hutch could feel his nervousness and he put his hand
on Starsky's arm, trying to give him a little calming energy. Tick, tick time
seemed to stand still for Starsky. The judge held in his hands the decision as
to whether the man who had taken away the love of his life would pay for that
crime, or whether he would be allowed to live.
Greanias handed the paper back to
the bailiff to be returned to the jury foreman. He said, "The defendant
will rise and face the jury."
The jury foreman took a deep breath
and started to read from the paper. "On case docket 80-843584, People vs.
George Prudholm in the matter of the murder of Teresa Renee Roberts. We the
jury, in the above entitled action, on the charge of Murder in the First Degree
with Special Circumstances do hereby find the defendant guilty as
charged."
A gasp went up from the courtroom
and several observers dashed out the door to announce the verdict to the media.
The judge banged his gavel, calling for order in the courtroom.
Starsky was tightly holding onto the
railing between his chair and the prosecution table. Hutch looked at him, but
couldn't read a reaction from his best friend. Then he realized that Starsky
was waiting to hear the judge's ruling.
"George Prudholm, you have been
found guilty of Murder in the First Degree with Special Circumstances. The
finding of Special Circumstances is in recognition to the cold, calculating way
you committed this crime. In the state of California, this finding bears with
it a mandatory death sentence. No penalty phase is necessary in this matter. I
hereby remand you to the custody of San Quentin State Prison. There you will
await the carrying out of your sentence, which will be conducted in the gas
chamber in accordance with state law, and may God have mercy on your soul. The jury
is dismissed with the thanks of this court. You have been an exemplary jury.
Court is now dismissed." The judge banged his gavel, and it was finally
over George Prudholm would pay for
Terry's death.
Starsky's head suddenly dropped
between his arms and Hutch was afraid he might pass out on them.
"Starsk?" he said, supporting his friend with an arm around the
waist. Starsky shook his head slightly, to let him know he was all right. After
a few minutes he looked up with both a smile and tears streaming down his face.
"Oh, God, Hutch, we won. Terry can rest in peace now." He turned and
grabbed onto Hutch with a tight embrace. Hutch patted him on the back saying,
"That's right, buddy. It's over and we won." Starsky felt Captain
Dobey put a supportive hand on his arm as he held onto Hutch. When he looked
up, the captain was smiling at him.
They all turned to Johnson, who
until now had just been watching the group. While they were savoring the
moment, Prudholm had been led out of the courtroom, too shocked by the verdict
to say anything else.
"Congratulations, Detective
Starsky. Was it worth it?" Johnson asked.
Starsky nodded, shook his hand, and
thanked him.
"You know he'll appeal
it."
Starsky smiled. "That don't
matter. He's gone. He's never going to hurt anyone again."
Hutch couldn't help thinking that
was right, especially not his partner.
Captain Dobey asked, "What are
you gonna do now, boys? You don't have to be at work until Monday. I'm giving
you the rest of the week off."
"Cap, I just want to go home
and get a real shower. We rushed out of the house this morning when we heard
the jury was done." Starsky looked relieved and happy. Hutch was glad to
see the tension begin to fade from his face and his body.
Hutch agreed to take Starsky back to
his apartment. He would go home too, clean up, and they would meet Dobey and
Johnson at Huggy's for a celebratory lunch at around two.
Dobey and Johnson preceded Starsky
and Hutch out of the courtroom and smack into the arms of representatives of
what looked like every TV and print media outlet in Bay City.
"Sergeant Starsky! Sergeant
Starsky!" The voices and microphones and tape recorders assaulted him from
every side.
"How do you feel about the
verdict, Sergeant?"
"Do you think your fiancιes
death has been avenged?"
"Will George Prudholm be
charged for the assault on Sergeant Hutchinson?"
Hutch, Dobey and Johnson tried to
surround Starsky and protect him from the barrage, but Starsky stood his
ground.
"I think we owe 'em a couple of
good quotes, don't you, Hutch?" He appealed to his partner as the one
person who would understand.
"Whatever you want to do,
Starsk."
Johnson glanced at them and nodded.
"Ladies and gentlemen!" he said, raising his voice. Instantly, the
cameras and microphones pointed at him. "I will make a brief statement,
and then Sergeant Starsky will speak."
Starsky waited.
Johnson didn't need notes. He was
used to speaking to the media. "Mr. Prudholm has been found guilty of
murder in the first degree with special circumstances. In California, that
means automatic death penalty. My office is satisfied that justice has been
served in this case. We presented our case, and the good citizens of Bay City
did the right thing." He stepped aside.
Dobey put a hand on Starsky's arm to
forestall him. "Captain Harold Dobey," he said, and spelled it for
them. "Too often, the police in this city and every city put their lives
on the line to protect the people and have to watch as the criminals they
arrest are set free. This time, that didn't happen. I'm proud of my officers
both these officers," he added, indicating Starsky and Hutch.
"They've been through a stressful experience and they maintained their
professionalism throughout."
Now all the attention was focused on
Starsky, who stepped forward and simply stood there for a moment, gathering his
thoughts. The reporters waited quietly. Finally, he looked up at them and that
"grave dignity" that Johnson had spoken of was in evidence again.
"I loved Terry Roberts," he said. "Her death was just wrong. She
helped people. She was a beautiful human being, inside, where it counts. She
didn't deserve to die at the hands of a man like George Prudholm. I can't say
I'm 'happy' about the verdict because, as my partner told me yesterday, it's a
serious thing to sentence a man to die, even a man like Prudholm. But I can say
I feel that Terry can rest in peace now. George Prudholm will pay for his
crime."
Johnson watched Starsky and when
Starsky gave him a little nod to indicate he was through, Johnson said,
"That's all. Let Sergeant Starsky go home and rest now. Any further
questions can be directed to the D.A.'s office."
Amazingly, the throng of reporters
parted and let them through.
TAG
At around one o'clock, Hutch pulled
up to the cemetery and saw Starsky's car there. He smiled at how they both
wound up here without discussing it first. He was on his way to The Pits and he
wanted to stop by and pay his respects to Terry first. He picked up the flowers
he had brought and started out to find his partner.
Walking across the neatly manicured
lawn, Hutch could see that his partner was sitting on the grass, talking to
Terry's grave. He didn't want to intrude and he almost turned to walk away when
Starsky looked up and saw him. His partner smiled and waved, signaling for Hutch
to come over to sit with him.
"Hi, Starsk. Been here a
while?"
"A little while. I just wanted
to come and tell her what happened. Wanted her to know she could rest easier
now. What are you doing here?"
"Same thing as you. I wanted to
tell her and thought this would be the best place to come. You okay,
Gordo?"
Starsky smiled at him. "Yep,
I'm fine, Hutch. Really fine for the first time in a long while. I don't know
why, Terry is still gone. Somehow, knowing Prudholm is going to pay for it
makes me feel better."
Starsky gently touched the grave
marker. He lovingly touched her name and read the passage from the Bible
Terry's mother had put on the marker.
Teresa
Renee Roberts
January
22, 1949 March 5, 1977
Beloved
Daughter
"Even
though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death
I
will fear no evil; for Thou art with me." Psalms 23, 4
Starsky thought about how often he
felt Terry's presence with him, just like she said she would be. "Rest
easy, sweetheart. It's all over now. Justice was served." Starsky's heart
was lighter than it had been in many years.
Looking at Hutch, he noticed the
flowers in his hand for the first time. "Roses, partner? You hate
roses."
Hutch smiled. "Yeah, I know,
but Terry loved them." He laid the flowers on her grave and sent her a
silent thank you for still being there for Starsky. He knew she would never
fail him.
Hutch stood up and offered his hand
to Starsky. "Come on, Gordo. We have some celebrating to do." Starsky
allowed Hutch to pull him to his feet and they walked out of the cemetery
together.
The End
Feedback? cruellaboris@yahoo.com